Italia New York Pizza

The chicken parm sub was clearly just frozen white chunks of chicken breast(?) that they may have possibly breaded themselves. Reheated or warmed up, tossed onto a somewhat decent roll, and covered in an obscene amount of cheese to obscure the fact that this soulless vestibule for calories is lacking in any flavor, character, or love.

The five-piece mozzarella stick order (significantly shorter in length than competitors' mozzarella sticks - yet similarly priced) lingered with the flavor of bottom shelf fry oil that they submerge it in to mostly cook it through. Decent amount of cheese inside, though. The marinara sauce was deplete of seasoning, had the viscosity of water, and didn't make the situation any better.

Reviews were overwhelmingly positive online which makes me question so many things. Have had the pizza before, huge miss. Perhaps this establishment is just living off of it's legacy from the past where it may have been a quality meal. No longer is that the case.

Staff was cordial. Parking was fine. Pricing scale wasn't terrible. But I'll probably have to be paid by someone in the future to ever eat here again. What a disappointment.

We usually do carry out, but what this place lacks in atmosphere, they more than make up with the food!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

The ingredients tasted incredibly fresh and well selected. The team provided outstanding service. I left with a big smile.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best place in town

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice little Italian restaurant with good food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The pizza is amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is your classic small town Italian pizzeria restaurant. The service is great and the food is good. They're great lunch specials Monday through Friday midday.

Old school deliciousness. Former NJ boy who's found a slice of food heaven outside of my old Jersey haunts. Yummy nom nom nom. Chicken Parm sandwich is perfection. Treat yourself.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Get the eggplant parm 🥰both the pasta dinner and sub are delicious! I also enjoy the pizzas, the crust is just right. You can also ask for whatever pasta and sauce you want, and add chicken or shrimp for an upcharge. So just because it isn't on the menu, that doesn't mean they're not willing to make it for you. Once you've placed several orders, they get to know you and how you like your salad, bread, etc. Great and quick service, thanks Javier!

Service: 5

Best NY style pizza in walkersville. Food is always on time for pick up and fresh out of the oven. They even have red pepper flakes and fresh grated cheese if you ask.

Great food, service was great and fast

The pizza and cakes only thing worth having. Very disappointed. When the older man is cooking food is better. The younger guy doesn't prepare food as good.
Ordered steak Stromboli for bf. He loves it and always says it great. I order vegetable one and it is the worse Stromboli ever!!! Been eating them for 20 years and the one here was so bad. They literally fried in grease some onions, peppers, black olives, mushrooms added salt and pepper with threw little cheese. Was awful. Tasted like grease No sauce. Every Stromboli ever had always had red sauce not here. They give sauce on the side. Gave another chance and ordered Ravolli. The sauce tastes burned. Couldn't finished it. Gave to grandson and he couldn't eat it either.
Honestly I suggest staying with their Pizza and that isn't always the same. If younger guy there the crust is soft. The older man it is more like NY style and crispy. I suggest staying with Pizza. Their cakes are great. Other than that I won't be ordering again. Gave too many chances and same results.
Also the younger man is little rude. Asked him to bake little longer so crust was crispy. He didn't. He said have a timer they use. Asked if he could cut pizza into smaller slices for the kids. Again he ignored the request. I have had better food and better service. Sorry. Wanted love this place.

I’m sorry Sean Silva stole your car.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Great food

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Sub

Was ok. Soda was gross.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2