Gelato Supreme Candy Shop & Ice Cream

Delicious gelato!! And they were open way later than other ice cream parlors on the main drag.

A sweet stop, this place is. 🍨🍬

If you have a sweet tooth, prepare your willpower. Mine disappeared almost immediately.

The candy selection is huge, with everything from nostalgic favorites to classic favorites, plus plenty of fun gifts and novelty snacks to browse while you wait.

The real star, though, was the gelato. I went with the caramel brownie and pistachio, and both were incredibly creamy, rich, and full of flavor. The caramel brownie was loaded with chocolatey goodness, while the pistachio had a smooth, authentic nutty flavor that kept me coming back for another bite. A combination worthy of a return visit, it is.

They also offer milkshakes, bubble waffles, smoothies, churros, and other desserts if you're looking for something beyond ice cream.

Trust your feelings on this one. Your sweet tooth will thank you.

Ice cream is great! A lot for the size and staff is nice!

Hands down the best ice cream we have ever had. Well worth the price in my opinion. The owners were so friendly! I couldn't believe how kind they were to my family and especially my little girl. We are only here for a short time, but so so happy we found this little gem!

Vegetarian options: Vegan ice cream options!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Strawberry Cheesecake Medium

Love this place!!! I come to OOB with my family every year and we’ve made it our tradition to stop at this shop every time! I love that it’s a family ran business and you can really tell how hard they work and how much they value customer service!! My husband and I are obsessed with the strawberry cheesecake gelato and our kids usually opt for candy. Love that they made the store bigger this year and we will def be back next year!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gelato, Giant Gummy Bear

Goated

Cheap stuff,prices aren't set, she obviously price based on jugements, and my plush had a hole in it! Don't recommend

The owners's response is a great example of her attitude :)

Service: 1

If I could give this shop a 0 rating I would! The customer service was awful and the environment was not child friendly. The clerk yelled at my child and her friend for touching one of the candies, stating that they were not “toys”. I nicely told the clerk that they were CHILDREN and that she could ask politely. She continued to argue with me and was very unprofessional. If you sell candy and candy that is packaged as toys, than you should expect that children will look, touch, etc. Needless to say we did not buy anything and will not be back!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Best ice cream you will find!!!!! Handmade and delicious!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They have ice cream and you can make any kind into milkshake! Perfect for any kind of day, I had a strawberry cheesecake milkshake ?. You can tell how hard they work.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This I would say is the best place to get an ice cream on the old orchard Boardwalk because they always have the quickest service and they have a wide selection of cone sizes you can get small medium large x large too they sell good types of candy's as well with there selections on ice cream and treats

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies and Cream

Delicious, cute & friendly! Overpriced @ almost 50$ For 4 medium ice creams, but it’s the best ice cream you will find anywhere and everything is over priced in oob. Also, they donate all the profits of toy sales to sick children. That’s a huge bonus!

Cute little shop for candy & ice cream! Customer service was great, and the ice cream was delicious. We got s’mores & cotton candy, both were very good. Definitely a nice quick stop while in OOB.

crooks! got charged 29.90 for 3 small cup of ice cream, my wife heard 20, which is already pretty expensive but we didn't ask first so she paid, after getting back we saw the real price on the statement, they're a bunch of thieft, you should get your ice cream elsewhere

Got overpriced 29$ US for 3 small ice cream . Total rip off