We ordered pizza by doordash today as I was feeling a bit under the weather. Just moved to the area so we had never been inside the restaurant. We ordered a small sausage and pepperoni pizza and a caramelized onion and pepper flatbread. Both were excellent! We will definitely dine in and try more items.
Corey Jackson
We were up for a family reunion and had a decent size order it was done in 30 minutes just like they said very friendly and nice place
John O'Keefe
Amazing Pizza.
Queen Moomba
This is a marvelous pizza joint. The dough is airy and the bottom was cooked great. The toppings for the pizzas are one of a kind for the area. They also sell some beers from a local brewery. Friendly staff. I do wish there was more seating but either way, it's 100% worth it.
Jacqui Pierce
Randomly stopped in here for a pizza last night and WOW! The staff was super nice and fast! The pizza: absolutely the best I've ever had. I ordered The Kind and had to stop myself from eating it all.. Amazing! Super fresh ingredients and amazing combinations.
tony P
Coming from Connecticut, York 54’s pizza does not disappoint! Great crust, cooked well and the toppings are great. We had the fig and salami white pie and the puttanesca red pie. Absolutely amazing! Shout to the cookie baker too, my daughters loved the Easter egg cookie! Connecticut loves York 54!
Jesse Marks
Just such an awesome spot. Amazing speciality service and the warmest, kindest staff anywhere. I'm from Colorado but stop here anytime in southern maine
Peter Duffy
Fantastic place! Awesome buffalo chicken quesadilla and york 54 salad
Edwin Reyes
I had the chicken Club Sandwich and it’s one of the best club sandwich I’ve ever had,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
emily meagher
They were so so nice. We were a little late to pick up our order and despite them closing they were so kind and warm towards us. This was our first time getting pizza from them and we will absolutely be back! Also the food was amazing!!
Visiting the area from upstate NY. Had a 12" pizza and it was excellent. The wings were good also.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Karen Libby
What a disappointment. Pizza and tenders seriously overcooked. Greek salad mediocre.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Grant Hagerty
After three long years (last year they were closed for renos, and the previous year, we landed on a Monday) we got to York 54 a half hour before closing, but the vibe and the flavours were top notch prime time !!
We shared the Beet and Blueberry salad and a Red Curry Thai pizza (did I mention this is my fave pie ever ?) and a Olive Branch pizza.
We left with grins on our faces ??? and we will be back on our next trip to Vacationland in 2025 !!
Best Pizza Ever !! Check opening times - this is not downtown pizza 24/7 and worth every cent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Olive Branch, Perfect, Red Thai Curry & Chicken Pesto Pizzas
Kayla Butcher
First of all, I was greeted with a smile and that's always appreciated. I struggled to make a lunch selection and went with the Avocado BLT on flatbread and WOW! I will be stopping here anytime I'm traveling through for work. Quality sandwich with amazing flavor. Far exceeded my expectations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Flatbread
Gerry S
The caramel chocolate brownie ice cream and the hard cider BBQ pizza were filling and yummy. The staff were very nice.
We ordered pizza by doordash today as I was feeling a bit under the weather. Just moved to the area so we had never been inside the restaurant. We ordered a small sausage and pepperoni pizza and a caramelized onion and pepper flatbread. Both were excellent! We will definitely dine in and try more items.
We were up for a family reunion and had a decent size order it was done in 30 minutes just like they said very friendly and nice place
Amazing Pizza.
This is a marvelous pizza joint. The dough is airy and the bottom was cooked great. The toppings for the pizzas are one of a kind for the area. They also sell some beers from a local brewery. Friendly staff. I do wish there was more seating but either way, it's 100% worth it.
Randomly stopped in here for a pizza last night and WOW! The staff was super nice and fast! The pizza: absolutely the best I've ever had. I ordered The Kind and had to stop myself from eating it all.. Amazing! Super fresh ingredients and amazing combinations.
Coming from Connecticut, York 54’s pizza does not disappoint! Great crust, cooked well and the toppings are great. We had the fig and salami white pie and the puttanesca red pie. Absolutely amazing! Shout to the cookie baker too, my daughters loved the Easter egg cookie! Connecticut loves York 54!
Just such an awesome spot. Amazing speciality service and the warmest, kindest staff anywhere. I'm from Colorado but stop here anytime in southern maine
Fantastic place! Awesome buffalo chicken quesadilla and york 54 salad
I had the chicken Club Sandwich and it’s one of the best club sandwich I’ve ever had,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They were so so nice. We were a little late to pick up our order and despite them closing they were so kind and warm towards us. This was our first time getting pizza from them and we will absolutely be back! Also the food was amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Visiting the area from upstate NY. Had a 12" pizza and it was excellent. The wings were good also.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
What a disappointment. Pizza and tenders seriously overcooked. Greek salad mediocre.
Food: 1
Service: 3
After three long years (last year they were closed for renos, and the previous year, we landed on a Monday) we got to York 54 a half hour before closing, but the vibe and the flavours were top notch prime time !!
We shared the Beet and Blueberry salad and a Red Curry Thai pizza (did I mention this is my fave pie ever ?) and a Olive Branch pizza.
We left with grins on our faces ??? and we will be back on our next trip to Vacationland in 2025 !!
Best Pizza Ever !! Check opening times - this is not downtown pizza 24/7 and worth every cent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Olive Branch, Perfect, Red Thai Curry & Chicken Pesto Pizzas
First of all, I was greeted with a smile and that's always appreciated. I struggled to make a lunch selection and went with the Avocado BLT on flatbread and WOW! I will be stopping here anytime I'm traveling through for work. Quality sandwich with amazing flavor. Far exceeded my expectations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Flatbread
The caramel chocolate brownie ice cream and the hard cider BBQ pizza were filling and yummy. The staff were very nice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hard Cider BBQ Pizza
Loading...