6 Best Pizza Restaurants near Glen Arbor

“You pay a bit of a premo price, but that's because you're in a tourist spot. However, the pizza is on point. I recommend you get the package deal, as it cam with bread and a 2 topping pizza that qas quite large, and quite delicious. Crust was crispy and chewy, cheese was melted ans stringy, and the sauce was flavored well. I'd definitely order from here again if I come to town in the future.“

“We had a wonderful New Year’s Eve dinner at Nonna’s. The surf and turf were very good. The beet salad, filet and the scallops were very good as well as the presentation and service. It is very convenient to have dinner at Nonna’s and not have to drive on New Years Eve.“

“My favorite food is pizza and my wife’s name is Millie so I had to stop in.

Pizza had a perfect crust - crispy on the bottom with a satisfying crunch, soft and fluffy on top. They clearly put care into the dough and it shows.

They have nice looking t-shirts for sale too, unfortunately they only had size small available.“

“Party of four had dinner there on July 4, 2025. Food was good, but not as advertised on the menu. The apple salad was small and did not have candied walnuts on it and the nachos had no cheese on them. The 1/2 ribs that my husband ordered were tasty, but we ended up ordering cheesy fries after our meals because we were still hungry. The ribs came with coleslaw and nothing else.The server was friendly and efficient.“

“great food and service, fast and easy.“

“I love coming here every time I’m in town and yesterday didn’t disappoint! And thanks for the great stories Riley! Can’t wait to come back!“