Closed permanently . I don't know why Jaap wants me to say more about this review, they're closed permanently, and their listing has not been updated.
Eric Brefka
If you're a fan of New York-style pizza, this is your spot. Big slices that are the perfect balance of not too greasy but not dried out either.The Parmigiana bites are an essential part of the experience.Delivery hours can be a bit strange and calling in does not always guarantee someone will answer. I highly suggest using the "Slice" app if you're ordering for delivery.
Jennifer Kawka
The used to have fantastic pizza but lately the pizzas haven't been hot at all. Not nearly enough sauce and to make matters worse lately they haven't been answering their phones on Sundays and Mondays. If that's not bad enough, today (Tuesday) the phone kept disconnecting.
Kasha Cockrell
I ordered a $30 pizza it was a 14 in. The pizza arrives and is cold....the cheese is literally firm. My husband calls to inform them and was treated with hostility and attitude. He was asked questions that had already been answered which tells me the person who answered wasn't listening! My husband was told "I'm not sending you another pizza if you've eaten some". EXCUSE ME? $30 for a pizza and you're telling me your not going to replace it because i ate 1 slice? We were promised a new pizza and told not to eat anymore. Needless to say I wasn't happy with his experience and called back for the manager. The OWNER who he spoke to saw nothing wrong with the way she handled our complaint. My order a few weeks ago was also cold because the driver got lost so I lost it and cussed her out! You won't get 3 strikes!
Melissa Wiles
This is the best pizza! I have been coming here for over 10 years. The economy is hard and covid is hurting these small businesses. They work hard to make good food. BUY THIS PIZZA!!!
Ted Hoeksema
The owners are wonderful , there pizza is so good , we have been back a few times . We have had there subs and Stromboli all excellent !! The large Stromboli could easily feed 3 people!
G Parker
Havent been able to afford only the best pizza ever! But it is the best pizza i have ever had!! Cant wait to have another slice of this authentic pizza! You cant go wrong! From the tastiest sauce to the crustiest of crust! All cooked to perfection! Beautiful!!!
Frederick Bennett
Over a $70 order and all the subs looked like this. Then they told us 45 minutes and it takes almost two hours and we gave you a $5 dollar tip so after taxes and all over $80. This is not acceptable at all.
Melissa Roelofs
Every time we’ve ordered from Carlos’s, the food has been phenomenal. To place an online order, you have to go through slice. The information slice has provided for Carlos’s isn’t always accurate. If you plan to order online, I’d recommend calling them to make sure what you want is correct and available. Not only is the food great, they are always helpful if we have questions!
Gina J
We decided to try a new place and something we never had before and wow! What a find! So delicious! We found a new go to place.
Delicious food, generous portions, and the best delivery driver in town!Thank you Stephanie for being fast, dependable, and for your amazing attitude. You brighten the office with every delivery.
Nathan Todd
Good food, locally owned. Pizza is always good.
Amanda McCallum
Not impressed at all. They offer pan square pizza by the slice but when I went to order one they were out of ALL of them. Ok, annoying but I got a mediocre slice of pepperoni for lunch and moved on. Then Ordered a tiramisu. To my surprise the tiramisu I ordered was ROCK SOLID FROZEN. Who serves someone a rock solid frozen piece of cake? There were visible frozen ice crystals on it. This was all through the drive though. First time there. Will definitely be my last.
Joe Zuiderveen
Great pizza, always ready on time, friendly staff
Sandra Morris
I’d change your name. The place on Plainfield uses your name and serves burnt food. Your food is great, definitely not the same place, but the owner states you are partners. Yuk
Closed permanently . I don't know why Jaap wants me to say more about this review, they're closed permanently, and their listing has not been updated.
If you're a fan of New York-style pizza, this is your spot. Big slices that are the perfect balance of not too greasy but not dried out either.The Parmigiana bites are an essential part of the experience.Delivery hours can be a bit strange and calling in does not always guarantee someone will answer. I highly suggest using the "Slice" app if you're ordering for delivery.
The used to have fantastic pizza but lately the pizzas haven't been hot at all. Not nearly enough sauce and to make matters worse lately they haven't been answering their phones on Sundays and Mondays. If that's not bad enough, today (Tuesday) the phone kept disconnecting.
I ordered a $30 pizza it was a 14 in. The pizza arrives and is cold....the cheese is literally firm. My husband calls to inform them and was treated with hostility and attitude. He was asked questions that had already been answered which tells me the person who answered wasn't listening! My husband was told "I'm not sending you another pizza if you've eaten some". EXCUSE ME? $30 for a pizza and you're telling me your not going to replace it because i ate 1 slice? We were promised a new pizza and told not to eat anymore. Needless to say I wasn't happy with his experience and called back for the manager. The OWNER who he spoke to saw nothing wrong with the way she handled our complaint. My order a few weeks ago was also cold because the driver got lost so I lost it and cussed her out! You won't get 3 strikes!
This is the best pizza! I have been coming here for over 10 years. The economy is hard and covid is hurting these small businesses. They work hard to make good food. BUY THIS PIZZA!!!
The owners are wonderful , there pizza is so good , we have been back a few times . We have had there subs and Stromboli all excellent !! The large Stromboli could easily feed 3 people!
Havent been able to afford only the best pizza ever! But it is the best pizza i have ever had!! Cant wait to have another slice of this authentic pizza! You cant go wrong! From the tastiest sauce to the crustiest of crust! All cooked to perfection! Beautiful!!!
Over a $70 order and all the subs looked like this. Then they told us 45 minutes and it takes almost two hours and we gave you a $5 dollar tip so after taxes and all over $80. This is not acceptable at all.
Every time we’ve ordered from Carlos’s, the food has been phenomenal. To place an online order, you have to go through slice. The information slice has provided for Carlos’s isn’t always accurate. If you plan to order online, I’d recommend calling them to make sure what you want is correct and available. Not only is the food great, they are always helpful if we have questions!
We decided to try a new place and something we never had before and wow! What a find! So delicious! We found a new go to place.
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious food, generous portions, and the best delivery driver in town!Thank you Stephanie for being fast, dependable, and for your amazing attitude. You brighten the office with every delivery.
Good food, locally owned. Pizza is always good.
Not impressed at all. They offer pan square pizza by the slice but when I went to order one they were out of ALL of them. Ok, annoying but I got a mediocre slice of pepperoni for lunch and moved on. Then Ordered a tiramisu. To my surprise the tiramisu I ordered was ROCK SOLID FROZEN. Who serves someone a rock solid frozen piece of cake? There were visible frozen ice crystals on it. This was all through the drive though. First time there. Will definitely be my last.
Great pizza, always ready on time, friendly staff
I’d change your name. The place on Plainfield uses your name and serves burnt food. Your food is great, definitely not the same place, but the owner states you are partners. Yuk