Old Pony Martini Pub
$$ • Bars, Cocktail Bar, BurgersAbout Old Pony Martini Pub
Customers' Favorites
Cheeseburger and Onion Rings
Cheeseburger and Wings
All Bottles of Beer
Select Beer Pints
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Tenders
Pineapple Whips
Chicken Wings
Double Burger
Craisin Salad
Old Pony Martini Pub Reviews
202 ratings
Share your opinion about Old Pony Martini Pub
We went to Old Pony Martini Bar and loved the atmosphere! It has the feel of a great old neighborhood corner bar, casual, friendly, and welcoming. The service was excellent, and our hamburgers were delicious with hot, crispy French fries. There was nothing better than an ice cold beer on a hot Sunday afternoon. It made for a perfect afternoon. We’ll definitely be back!
Great martinis. Solid menu. They have food as well. Busy and fun atmosphere. I'd for sure go back!
Burgers were bomb. Worth it
Hours
| Monday | 3PM - 12AM |
| Tuesday | 3PM - 12AM |
| Wednesday | 3PM - 12AM |
| Thursday | 3PM - 12AM |
| Friday | 3PM - 12AM |
| Saturday | 12PM - 12AM |
| Sunday | 12PM - 12AM |
Old Pony Martini Pub is a popular spot known for its excellent service and delicious food. The martini special is a favorite among customers, and the burgers are highly recommended. The staff, including Patty, Justin, and two other girls, are friendly and make visitors feel welcome. The pub offers great drinks and tasty dishes, such as the double cheeseburger and totchos, which are especially delicious. Customers praise the smash burgers and dill garlic fries, calling them to die for and saying photos don’t do them justice. Many find the food worth the short drive from their homes. The pub is also known for its great staff who work hard to ensure everyone has a good experience. It remains a friendly place for both regulars and newcomers, providing a warm and lively atmosphere. Although some note that the place has become louder recently, shifting from a quiet restaurant to a noisier, college bar-like environment, many still enjoy visiting, especially for the great drinks and friendly staff. The pub has also catered large groups successfully, such as a varsity football team, serving 100 burgers fresh and warm after practice. Additionally, it is a popular venue for special events, with one customer describing their surprise party for their wife as executed perfectly from start to finish.