Amy J's Pasty
$ • Bakery
Hours:
1000 N Lincoln Dr, Hancock
(906) 482-2253
About Amy J's Pasty
Customers' Favorites
Amy J's Pasty Reviews
Share your opinion about Amy J's Pasty
I stopped in just as they opened on a Monday and ordered a large pasty with meat. I also got a bran muffin and peanut butter cookie. The pasty was outstanding! The best combination/proportion of beef and vegetables I’ve ever had in a pasty. The crust was a great compliment. My vote for #1 in the UP!!! The muffin and cookie were also very good. I’ll definitely make the effort to stop whenever I’m in the area.
Great pasty! Highly recommend, will be back soon.
Highly NOT recommended!
Shipping fee, for 36 Pasties, via UPS was astronomical and way above what should have been charged.
Additionally, the amount of rutabaga was extremely small. Barely could tell any was in the Pasties.
Lawry’s Pasties in Marquette charges half what Amy’s does for shipping
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11:30AM - 5:30PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:30AM - 5:30PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 5:30PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
People in Hancock Also Viewed
Amy J's Pasty is a charming shop serving delicious pasties and baked goods. Fresh and hot pasties are always available, making it a popular spot in the Keweenaw area. The bakery is renowned for its mouth-watering chocolate chip cookies, peanut butter cookie, and bran muffin. Visitors can enjoy a wonderful homemade pasty in this old gas station-turned-shop. Customers praise the authentic and delicious pasties, which are served warm and are the best combination of beef and vegetables. Many visitors find this place by chance and are glad they did, often ordering a large pasty or some to take for later. The staff is super helpful and nice, creating a comfortable atmosphere whether dining inside or getting takeout. The shop also offers cookies and cinnamon rolls, making it a delightful stop for baked goods. Overall, Amy J's Pasty is considered the best place to get a pasty in the UP, with great prices and consistently delicious food.