12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hickory Corners

“I have come here quiet a few times over the years and haven't had a problem. I am a stickler for customer service though. I don't know who trains the ones that work at the take out counter, but there needs to be more!!!! Picked up an order and there was NO thank you, have a good night, or no smile!!! I didnt even know if the receipt was mine, she sort of just tossed it onto the box. Good old customer service is your first in with the community!!!“

“Literally the best pizza to ever exist. 903747472883844799/10. Traveled 600 miles salivating over the thought of a Steve’s Pizza from home, and last night’s order did not disappoint (as always, duh) Simply, the GOAT of pizza.“

“Thank you for going out of your way to make pizzas for our kid’s birthday party You had them ready and hot for us to pick up!!! So appreciate you The pizza was amazing and everyone ate and filled right up!!!!!!! Great pizza and food and service“

“We ordered two small pizzas-- an 8" spicy supreme and chicken alfredo. Both were very flavorful and heavy with toppings. Perfectly sized for two meals.“

“One of our Friends recently ordered Pizza from here after our Pickleball session. We got couple of Large vegetarian Pizzas. They were fresh, full of flavor and very delicious. Although it took them a while to deliver the pizza but they were really hot. Everything from sauce to cheese is well balanced. This is one if the better Pizza's we have had it in a while. It was pretty fulfilling and we ended up playing few extra games lol. Will definitely order again from here.“

“Was on golf trip with 11 others. Local one of my favorite stops especially on Monday. Felt sorry for staff 1 bartender / server. place was almost full and coming in with 10 guys at once made it full. Food is good do recommend if you get a 24 in pizza ask for brown or well done.“

“Great food“

“So my boyfriend and I went in tonight 11/18/25 I must say the two guys working very welcoming and we were treated amazing! we did not exactly know what to order so they both were very knowledgeable and helped us create the most delicious sandwich! we had a wonderful experience and definitely recommend you go here! also they are so well priced better then subway with higher quality food and bigger sandwiches! This place is a winner!“

“Orangeville Tavern is hands down the best place for pizza! Their wood-fired pizza is out of this world—crispy crust, amazing toppings, and so much flavor. The service is always great, and the staff are super friendly. If you haven’t been here yet, you’re missing out!“

“Stop in for a great pizza or some lottery, and perhaps you might be the next lucky customer to purchase a winning Club Keno ticket worth $10,000 like some unknown customer did on February 3, 2020. Perhaps the bartender knows, hope the winner tipped good!“

“My wife and I came in for the special dinner. The bartender, Darla, even though she was very busy was still very attentive. We ordered the shrimp cocktail and the smoked prime rib dinner. All of which was amazing. It was cooked exactly how we ordered it. The portion sizes were just enough. This was our first time here after just moving into the area and will for sure be back. Very clean, great food and very friendly staff.“

“Ordered a large number of pizzas for a reunion, 14 then added 1 then ordered 8 more. I had contacted the Gull Roaf location in Kalamazoo and talked with Judas. She was extremely patient and helpful. Judas was there to assemble the pizzas perfectly. The pizzas were ready on time and kept hot. Everyone complimented our choice of food. I was very pleased with Judas and her help with this order. She went above and beyond and i appreciate her cooperation.“