Pizza was great! Brought to a customer and the guys couldn't get over how huge this pizza was when I brought it in! Fun "novelty" but also a good pizza! Great service too!
Dorothy Belmore
OMG. The best pizza I have ever tasted. The size is crazy. One slice equals about 3 regular sliced pizza. lol.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Neeta Karani
Outrageously huge pizza that remind me of the east coast. Delicious! Indoor dining area is limited for bigger parties. Not many topping or customization options but that just makes it easy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Slice
Mike White
I took my wife and kids here for an afternoon out. And we have all been wanting to give them a try. Walked in and was greeted right away and took our order.My wife and kids got served their slice is a timely matter. They were more than half way done and the worker told me mine was still gonna be awhile. By the time I received my slice everyone at the table was done already then made me look like they we were waiting on me.Not sure why I was the chosen one but atleast everyone else got theirs in an ok time. Was a shame couldn't enjoy the slice with the fam tho.
We've been twice before, both good experiences. This one (2/10/24 noonish) was not. Only one other table of 3 was there before us but staff wasn't very personable plus empty tables were dirty. The wait for one slice each (2 people) took nearly 15 minutes despite it being lunchtime. Women's restroom was out of order, men's was filthy, and its soap dispenser was broken. Very disappointing because the pizza itself is absolutely delicious, but we'll be thinking twice before returning again unfortunately.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Sliced Italian Sausage Slice, Garlic Mushroom Slice
Michael Thayer
Meh. Not bad but not great. A solid B.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Reverend Oats
Benny Diabetes. Stay. Away.
Adam Herrick
Staff was amazing. Love that I can bring in an outside beer. Sliced are ABSOLUTELY ridiculously enormous.
Could be the best valued and tasting pizza in town. Seriously 6 bucks gets you a very large slice. Love the slightly spicy tomato sauce. Not hot just flavorful spicy.
Skyler Sawle
Closed 30mins early and couldn’t get anything don’t go here done this 3 times change hours or don’t be open till 12
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Amy Siler
Very good slice of old style pizza. Absolutely delicious, and I will be going
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Frank Clark
Delicious pizza, one slice can fill you up but the flavor will leave you wanting more. Still so good, glad this is a place that has stayed open.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Mushroom Pizza
dee3598 dee3598
I was really hoping Benny DiCarta's pizza would be delicious, but sadly, it was just mediocre. Crust is really great, but the sauce is sorely lacking in flavor and very sparse.Parking: You've got to hope you get lucky and can find a parking spot on Michigan Ave. Only other choice is to pay $5 in a lot behind the pizza place which is not viable for just a pick-up.
Fantastic customer service and great New York slices here in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Garlic Mushroom Pizza
Absolutely LOVE everything
Pizza was great! Brought to a customer and the guys couldn't get over how huge this pizza was when I brought it in! Fun "novelty" but also a good pizza! Great service too!
OMG. The best pizza I have ever tasted. The size is crazy. One slice equals about 3 regular sliced pizza. lol.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Outrageously huge pizza that remind me of the east coast. Delicious! Indoor dining area is limited for bigger parties. Not many topping or customization options but that just makes it easy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Slice
I took my wife and kids here for an afternoon out. And we have all been wanting to give them a try. Walked in and was greeted right away and took our order.My wife and kids got served their slice is a timely matter. They were more than half way done and the worker told me mine was still gonna be awhile. By the time I received my slice everyone at the table was done already then made me look like they we were waiting on me.Not sure why I was the chosen one but atleast everyone else got theirs in an ok time. Was a shame couldn't enjoy the slice with the fam tho.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Regular Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Cheese Slice
We've been twice before, both good experiences. This one (2/10/24 noonish) was not. Only one other table of 3 was there before us but staff wasn't very personable plus empty tables were dirty. The wait for one slice each (2 people) took nearly 15 minutes despite it being lunchtime. Women's restroom was out of order, men's was filthy, and its soap dispenser was broken. Very disappointing because the pizza itself is absolutely delicious, but we'll be thinking twice before returning again unfortunately.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Sliced Italian Sausage Slice, Garlic Mushroom Slice
Meh. Not bad but not great. A solid B.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Benny Diabetes. Stay. Away.
Staff was amazing. Love that I can bring in an outside beer. Sliced are ABSOLUTELY ridiculously enormous.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Slice
Restaurantji Recommends
Could be the best valued and tasting pizza in town. Seriously 6 bucks gets you a very large slice. Love the slightly spicy tomato sauce. Not hot just flavorful spicy.
Closed 30mins early and couldn’t get anything don’t go here done this 3 times change hours or don’t be open till 12
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Very good slice of old style pizza. Absolutely delicious, and I will be going
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Delicious pizza, one slice can fill you up but the flavor will leave you wanting more. Still so good, glad this is a place that has stayed open.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Mushroom Pizza
I was really hoping Benny DiCarta's pizza would be delicious, but sadly, it was just mediocre. Crust is really great, but the sauce is sorely lacking in flavor and very sparse.Parking: You've got to hope you get lucky and can find a parking spot on Michigan Ave. Only other choice is to pay $5 in a lot behind the pizza place which is not viable for just a pick-up.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4