Our food was great and the bartender was super friendly and helpful! We had the broiled whitefish and fish tacos.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sherri Bagalay
The potatoes..... Really, that potatoes are absolutely plate licking good. The steak was done perfectly! Great texture, perfect amount of red for a med-rare. The waitress was down to earth and easy to converse with. The only complaint is the lack of availability of items at end of season, but understandable. Something to note if you try to hit up the island for fall, they start running things out for the season end.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Winfield
Really enjoyed our meal here! The server was outstanding. It’s a smaller room so my only issue was that it was very loud to have any sort of a conversation at your table. But we’d certainly come back next time!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nora German
We went to Millie’s on Main while on a girls trip to the Island for a week. I was a little hesitant as the menu isn’t huge and I like a little more variety. We decided to try it because it was close to our hotel and has options the three of us would all eat. We got in and waited slightly longer than we expected in not huge one room place . Finally someone came and sat us. I’m happy to say that it was all uphill from there . The inside is cute and charming , nothing super fancy but cozy. There was a short wait so we opted to sit at the bar and get some drinks. The bartender, Traci was fast and the drinks were fantastic . We all were pleasantly surprised as this seemed more of a place for beer rather than some very well made cocktails. Our server was Brooke T. Was amazing ! She has such a great personality and was a fun and attentive server who gave us great recommendations and was just great from start to finish. My friend got the unplanked whitefish which was so good and not fishy like another whitefish we had at another restaurant on the island . I got the chicken which was very good. Another friend got the Neptune’s pasta which was also very tasty. They didn’t have scallops due to the close of the season but they still charge the same Price which I feel should not be the case. On Brooke’s recommendation we tried the pumpkin spice latte cake and we also wanted to try the apple crisp. Both were fantastic ! Everyone loved my espresso martini (even the non martini fan.) The not your average margarita was a nice surprise too and we all loved it (yep even the non margarita fan). Once it got dark out the ambience was really nice and it was nicely decorated for Halloween. Definitely underrated and so glad we ended up going there .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Unplanked Whitefish
Annette LaCoy
I was there on Monday with 5 others. I am giving this a 3 star only because the food was amazing and our server was excellent! If it wasn’t for that it would be a 1 star! The hostess was unbelievably rude to my mother who needs a walker to get around. I guess your establishment had never heard of The Americans with Disabilities Act! She insisted the walker had to be left outside which is unacceptable! I offered to have it folded up right next to my leg and the bench in the front of the restaurant. She said it wasn’t allowed! When she wasn’t seating people she sat on the front bench reading a book! As we were leaving the waitress offered to get my my her walker and to put down the ramp to make it easier. Too bad the hostess didn’t offer to do that. Luckily the walker was still outside otherwise my Mother would have been stranded. I will say all the other restaurants we went to on the island were very accommodating especially The Pink Pony and The Great Turtle!
Kinzie Hales
Good food and great service. The meatloaf was great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Comey (Turn The Dial Coaching)
Very cool vine in what looks like an old saloon. We had the famous meatloaf which was delicious and perfect to feed two people. We also got the fried green beans which we HIGHLY RECOMMEND. Service is excellent. Give them a shot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kate Chartrand
Wonderful lunch spot while on the island! We had chicken tortilla soup and a pastie, both very good! Friendly staff and cool interior, would go back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Yooper Beef Pastie
Amber Rose
This place is a hidden gem. We were looking for a good hearty meal after a weekend of drinking. This place exceeded our expectations. Food was AMAZING. We sat at the bar and Brooke the bartender was super friendly. She provided recommendations on drinks and food. Advised all sauces for the food were made to order. We ordered the Perch and the Chicken Alfredo as well as the blueberry martini (puree was fresh) Best food on the island for sure! We talked about this food the whole way home. Cant wait to return!
The food was really good but very expensive. Service was slow, but the atmosphere was outstanding.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Zach Wilson
Food: all the food was incredible! Classic burger, chicken Alfredo, and meatloaf sliders were excellent
Service: very attentive, friendly, and helpful. Quality professional staff
Atmosphere: smaller setting but great atmosphere and ambiance
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley J
We loved the steak and potatoes so much last year that we made a trip back with this as our "main event" lol They raised their prices and charged extra for double potatoes-which we expected a little increase bc of the times changing but the extra $10 for double potatoes each really took me by surprise-waitress could've told us there'd be an upcharge-but oh well-we went for those 2 things specifically! Even well done the steak is so tender and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Randall Ehrlinger
Burgers are awesome
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chandy Byrum
We were a party of 4 who each loved their meals. The ribs were to die for and the most flavorful New York strip we've ever had. We actually ate two meals there, we were so pleased.
Our food was great and the bartender was super friendly and helpful! We had the broiled whitefish and fish tacos.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The potatoes..... Really, that potatoes are absolutely plate licking good. The steak was done perfectly! Great texture, perfect amount of red for a med-rare. The waitress was down to earth and easy to converse with. The only complaint is the lack of availability of items at end of season, but understandable. Something to note if you try to hit up the island for fall, they start running things out for the season end.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really enjoyed our meal here! The server was outstanding. It’s a smaller room so my only issue was that it was very loud to have any sort of a conversation at your table. But we’d certainly come back next time!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went to Millie’s on Main while on a girls trip to the Island for a week. I was a little hesitant as the menu isn’t huge and I like a little more variety. We decided to try it because it was close to our hotel and has options the three of us would all eat. We got in and waited slightly longer than we expected in not huge one room place . Finally someone came and sat us. I’m happy to say that it was all uphill from there . The inside is cute and charming , nothing super fancy but cozy. There was a short wait so we opted to sit at the bar and get some drinks. The bartender, Traci was fast and the drinks were fantastic . We all were pleasantly surprised as this seemed more of a place for beer rather than some very well made cocktails. Our server was Brooke T. Was amazing ! She has such a great personality and was a fun and attentive server who gave us great recommendations and was just great from start to finish. My friend got the unplanked whitefish which was so good and not fishy like another whitefish we had at another restaurant on the island . I got the chicken which was very good. Another friend got the Neptune’s pasta which was also very tasty. They didn’t have scallops due to the close of the season but they still charge the same
Price which I feel should not be the case. On Brooke’s recommendation we tried the pumpkin spice latte cake and we also wanted to try the apple crisp. Both were fantastic ! Everyone loved my espresso martini (even the non martini fan.) The not your average margarita was a nice surprise too and we all loved it (yep even the non margarita fan). Once it got dark out the ambience was really nice and it was nicely decorated for Halloween. Definitely underrated and so glad we ended up going there .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Unplanked Whitefish
I was there on Monday with 5 others. I am giving this a 3 star only because the food was amazing and our server was excellent! If it wasn’t for that it would be a 1 star! The hostess was unbelievably rude to my mother who needs a walker to get around. I guess your establishment had never heard of The Americans with Disabilities Act! She insisted the walker had to be left outside which is unacceptable! I offered to have it folded up right next to my leg and the bench in the front of the restaurant. She said it wasn’t allowed! When she wasn’t seating people she sat on the front bench reading a book! As we were leaving the waitress offered to get my my her walker and to put down the ramp to make it easier. Too bad the hostess didn’t offer to do that. Luckily the walker was still outside otherwise my Mother would have been stranded. I will say all the other restaurants we went to on the island were very accommodating especially The Pink Pony and The Great Turtle!
Good food and great service. The meatloaf was great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very cool vine in what looks like an old saloon. We had the famous meatloaf which was delicious and perfect to feed two people. We also got the fried green beans which we HIGHLY RECOMMEND. Service is excellent. Give them a shot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful lunch spot while on the island! We had chicken tortilla soup and a pastie, both very good! Friendly staff and cool interior, would go back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Yooper Beef Pastie
This place is a hidden gem. We were looking for a good hearty meal after a weekend of drinking. This place exceeded our expectations. Food was AMAZING. We sat at the bar and Brooke the bartender was super friendly. She provided recommendations on drinks and food. Advised all sauces for the food were made to order. We ordered the Perch and the Chicken Alfredo as well as the blueberry martini (puree was fresh) Best food on the island for sure! We talked about this food the whole way home. Cant wait to return!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was really good but very expensive. Service was slow, but the atmosphere was outstanding.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Food: all the food was incredible! Classic burger, chicken Alfredo, and meatloaf sliders were excellent
Service: very attentive, friendly, and helpful. Quality professional staff
Atmosphere: smaller setting but great atmosphere and ambiance
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We loved the steak and potatoes so much last year that we made a trip back with this as our "main event" lol
They raised their prices and charged extra for double potatoes-which we expected a little increase bc of the times changing but the extra $10 for double potatoes each really took me by surprise-waitress could've told us there'd be an upcharge-but oh well-we went for those 2 things specifically!
Even well done the steak is so tender and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Burgers are awesome
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were a party of 4 who each loved their meals. The ribs were to die for and the most flavorful New York strip we've ever had. We actually ate two meals there, we were so pleased.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...