Teddy Spaghettis

513 W Pontaluna Rd, Norton Shores
(231) 777-8337

Recent Reviews

Aimee Carter

Service was exceptional and inviting. Had a comfort food vibe when we picked up our food. The cracked pizza was yummy and the chocolate chip cookie was a must. Also the homemade bread on Teddy’s sub was SO good! Will come back.

Anthony Pumphrey

Great service, great atmosphere - food is MUCH better than the alternative, but not quite as good as expected. If they weren't closing on April 1st, I'd definitely come back.

Nathan Powell

The last time I was able to go before they close for good, they started cutting their entrees in half to make food cost. I wish I had known, would've ordered more food. Had chicken parm, so did my friend. They split the usual portion between his plate and mine. We're usually big fans of the place, it was sad. Waitress went to ask staff if that was the new normal and she said "yeah the cooks said they did used to be bigger, sorry about that." Not her fault but we spent over 60 bucks between my date and I, I'd hoped to leave with full stomach.

Jillian G.

The food is always delicious, the service is always on point with friendly service, and it's such a cute little place. The pizza is always good, as well as the pasta, breadsticks and anything I've tried. 10/10

Christine S.

If you ate getting, what we Americans call traditional Italian food, spaghetti, lasagna, ravioli, I would say you are safe. As mentioned before, much like others, my husband loves the thick garlic bread. The last two times we were very disappointed with our meals. A rating of one would be generous. The chicken tetrazzini came out with rubber chicken, we mentioned this to our waitress, she apologized and said she would let the chef know. More recently we tried the special, which was a mushroom sauce with steak, served over fettuccine noodles. Even worse then the rubber chicken, was the inedible steak. Once you cut the fat away you were left with very little meat. The large pieces of meat were so tough I could not cut them with my knife. So we ate our salad, breadstick, and noodles with sauce. I showed the waitress my plate of fat and meat that could not be chewed. She apologized and took $5.00 off the meal. If we go back we will stick with the Italian dishes we know to be good. One other thing, although there seems to be turn around with the wait staff, we have always had courteous, pleasant, attentive waiters and waitresses.

Marissa F.

Friendly service. Love the toasted raviolis. Can be dry at times. Small seated area. Clean. I primarily do takeout. Overall would recommend.

John W.

skimpy pizza. ordered a pepperoni double cheese they charged me $28 dollars for it and the whole pizza didnt have 20 pepperonis on it called and complained and they didn't see to be too concerned about it. we will never go back even though we only live a half a mile away

Beth S.

Delicious food, wonderful people and service and I highly recommend. Small and quaint inside and if that isn't your thing they have takeout that doesn't take long.

Blaire Novick

Very disappointed. I ordered chicken parm for take out. The chicken was the tiniest portion I've ever had. It was dry and I asked for extra mozzarella and there was literally almost NO mozzarella. The bread that came w/the meal was the worst; dry and dirty! The side salad was alright. Overall, the meal was cold and the pasta was drenched w/way too much raw garlic! For $25, this was incredibly disappointing. Will never return.

F2524BWtima

We had called ahead to get a table reserved as we were driving over 30 minutes, on our way in, we were called 10 minutes out stating our table is ready. I told her we were 10 minutes out and told your tables ready for you, only to find out that our table was taken by someone else. Annoying but given it's a Saturday night, we could deal. What we can't deal with is the lousy service. The eye rolls for asking for drinks without ice is unnecessary. Acting like customers ordering food is an inconvenience is unnecessary. We have not had poor service or food to this scale until this evening. Afterwards, when we got up to pay I don't know who was more happy to leave, us or your employee. Service should mean something, and it's clearly lacking here

Caroline Schillaci

Our server Emily with the beautiful red hair exceeded our expectations service wise. And the food..wow where do I begin. Although my stomach is throbbing and I might need to go to the ER, I don’t regret a single bite. It was so delicious I couldn’t stop eating from the generous portion of my pasta. Highly recommend to anyone seeking some comfort (food)

lance G.

Good is great and the staff are extremely friendly. Everything in their menu tastes great especially their fried cannelloni. Don't forget to try their cannolis!

Shalmendo

My mate and I had paesano bread. I had a salad and Spaghetti with meatballs. My mate had carbonara. It was beyond amazing! The meatballs were excellent, well cooked with excellent spices. The sauce was perfect. And the portions were larger then expected!The waitress was exceedingly fun and friendly and we had a great time despite making reservations that turned out to be unnecessary.Will eat here again next time we pass through!Just between us I think this place has better food then our local Italian place!

Kelly Remus

The portions are HUGE. The food was delicious. We got the lasagna, the Alfredo and spaghetti. Everything was very filling. The atmosphere was lovely and the staff was kind with good suggestions. I would like about 10 more loaves of that bread

Dav S

Wasn't sure what to expect going in.WOW !Awesome Italian food.Good sized portions.I had the Grande and was nearly full when I took this picture and you can see I only made a dent.No bread sticks, but, I got a loaf of (sourdough?) bread with parmigian on top with my meal.I had the Sunny Sicilian, the sun dried tomatoes were flavorful and just the right amount of spice.I would go here over Olive Garden any chance I could get.Looking forward to returning and trying other dishes.2 meals and 2 alcoholic drinks $45

Load More