Brewster's New Buffalo
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-3005
Recent Reviews
Sort by
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-3005
We love Brewsters! Food is always on point. Service is outstanding too. We love the cookies - make sure to ask your server to warm it up for you!
Solid meal, every dish was very good. Nice setting, very fun wait staff. Place was packed and bit loud. Not a problem for us !
Just a great place for dinner. Had the short ribs which were awesome!!!!! Would definitely go back! Thank you
Can always count on great food, service and atmosphere at Brewster's. It's worth our drive from Elkhart.
Server was knowledable about the menu and spoke with the kitchen about allergies. Gluten Free!
Took two hours to be served. Many things were forgotten. Hard to justify the large bill when you have poor service.
Sat outside. Weather was great and garden beautiful. Waitress was awesome and ver attentive.
Food and ambiance was superb! Service was a little slow but it was Later in the evening on a busy night so I give some grace! Love Brewsters!
We have been going to Brewsters for over 25 years and it is always excellent food, atmosphere and service!
We had such a wonderful meal at Brewster's! Our reservation (highly recommended!) was for outside and despite a recent shower, our table was (mostly) dry and perfect for our party of 8. The patio is as beautiful as the food is delicious. A don't-miss restaurant in NB!
Restaurantji Recommends
We had a fabulous dinner. The service was quick but we weren't rushed. The food and drink were fantastic! We sat outside and the temperature was perfect. This is the go-to place in New Buffalo.
Dani was an amazing server! So attentive and cheerful! We will definitely be requesting her next time we dine there in the future.
The food was amazing great taste and flavors. It was our first time in, my wife and I had a date night and we both thoroughly enjoyed our time together and raved about how delicious everything was. We will definitely be back.
Our waiter Dan was a 20/10. Best service. Food is always amazing. A must stop if you're in New Buffalo.
While we dined outdoors, the interior space looks amazing after their refresh. Despite it being very hot out, the patio stays cool and is amply shaded. Our server was great as was the food and drink!
Loading...