Casey's New Buffalo

$$ • Bar & Grill, American

136 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-6400


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Casey's New Buffalo

Stopped in on a Tuesday at 1 pm. Sat in back patio section. Took the waiter a bit to get to us but he was very busy. I had the Mahi Mahi tacos and my companion had a grilled cheese with smoked bacon and blueberry jam. Both entrees were tasty. The pineapple slaw is especially good.

Lovely little restaurant just a couple of blocks from the beach. My burger and my wife's chicken sandwich were very good straight from the kitchen. Bit of our sides were lacking though. The portion size of the sides are embarrassingly small. My broccoli salad needed more binder/mayo and my wife's pineapple Slaw was just a little plain.

Get the Power Bowl. Bartender was spectacular. I am sorry I have forgotten her name as we went a couple of weeks ago. Service was friendly and efficient. Atmosphere is perfect bar/Cafe without loud music so you could actually have conversations without losing your voice. I only wish we didn't live 3 hours away . This is a great, homey, regular kind of spot.

More Reviews(209)


Monday 12PM - 12AM
Tuesday 12PM - 12AM
Wednesday 12PM - 12AM
Thursday 12PM - 12AM
Friday 12PM - 2AM
Saturday 12PM - 2AM
Sunday 12PM - 12AM