Brewster's New Buffalo

$$ • Italian, Pizza

11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-3005


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Brewster's New Buffalo

Took a friend who had not been to Brewster's before but had heard it was a favorite in my family. He enjoyed it very much, both ambiance and our great server Brandy. Had a reservation; for some reason the hostess took us to a small table for two. When I asked for a larger table she did not hesitate, and we had elbow room in a lovely spot. My friend reported the pastrami was very good. I always enjoy Brewster's food.

Food was SUPER !!! I had the spaghetti and HOMEMADE meatballs in HOMEMADE sauce. 5 BIG meatballs in a bowlful of perfect pasta!!!! Fabulous!!! My wife had one of the specials with chicken, risotto and tiny little peppers that gave it a really good zip. Wine was very good and a reasonable price. Desert was a Lemon cake that was delightful. Went back the next day for really good personal sized pizzas. Brewsters is a WINNER!!!!! Only "negative" is that they ask for you to add a full review

The cappuccino was amazing! The mess breakfast was really good. It is super quaint inside. It reminds me of an old house. It has pictures of old time families which adds to the charm. I would definitely go here again.

More Reviews(922)


Monday 9AM - 9PM
Tuesday 9AM - 9PM
Wednesday 9AM - 9PM
Thursday 9AM - 9PM
Friday 9AM - 10PM
Saturday 9AM - 10PM
Sunday 9AM - 9PM