What are you looking for?

Pizza Restaurants in New Buffalo

4.6 - 1032 votes

Hours: 9AM - 10PM

11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-3005

Papa Johns Pizza

Seated at proper time, table ready. Server brought menus and bread fairly quickly. Food took some time to arrive even though the restaurant wasn’t near... More reviews

4.3 - 446 votes

Hours: 12PM - 12AM

245 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-2727

Papa Johns Pizza

Been here several times and it's way overrated! Went for my birthday and the unfriendly hostess began taking us back to the afterthought add on room... More reviews

3.6 - 140 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

17600 Red Arrow Hwy, New Buffalo
(269) 469-3698

Papa Johns Pizza

The waitress was very good! But she had to apologize because the establishment was out of ketchup, and then had to apologize to another table for being o... More reviews

3.7 - 296 votes

Hours: 12 - 11PM

134 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-0200

Papa Johns Pizza

Great service. The pizza is a thin crispy crust. Spent $30 for pizza and two drinks. To see our adventures subscribe to SIMPLE LIFE BIG ADVENTURES on You... More reviews

View on map