Pizza Restaurants near New Buffalo

Brewster's New Buffalo Italian • $$
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Any Two Toppings Thin Crust Only
Spinach Artichoke Dip
House Salad & Soup
Charcuterie Board
Ice Cream Sundae
Dinner for Two
Shrimp Alfredo
Dressing
Asparagus
Cookies

“Honestly, the food was pretty decent. My partner really loved the pasta (chicken alfredo). The pizza was alright, slightly burnt around the edges. The “dinner for two deal” ($55) was a decent deal for the food you got. Came with soup/salad, one (2 topping) pizza, a main entree (pasta), and dessert (coffee and a cookie). Did get a 3% fee, which we didn’t know about.“

4.5 Superb393 Reviews
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
245 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Short Rib Grilled Cheese
Southwest Egg Rolls
Fish Tacos Tilapia
Beer Battered Cod
Nachos Appetizer
Shrimp Tacos
Cheese Curds
Chicken Wings
Sandwiches
Mahi Tacos

“Passing the signs on the freeway for this place for a long time finally got a chance to stop in. Food was actually pleasantly good. Service was good food came out pretty quick very tasty.Place very clean atmosphere good.Will stop by there again. Everything is extra so if you get a burger or a sandwich to the fries or onion rings are an extra charge. !! And for the dollar value I would get the onion rings they're in a bigger basket the fries for the money you don't get that much“

4.4 Superb197 Reviews
Villa Nova Pizzeria - New Buffalo Italian • $
134 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Italian Beef Sandwich
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Breadsticks with Cheese
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Pizza by the Slice
Marinara Sauce
Pretzel Bites
French Fries
Caprese Salad

“What a great surprise! I was a little hesitant taking my family here, based on past reviews. I'm so glad we came though, because everything was TERRIFIC! We had the best service and the food was soooo good. All of it. I'm picky and I was super happy.Only issue is the seating. We were on high boys and it made me uneasy with my little ones. There was a private party in the next room, otherwise I'm sure we would have had different seating. I bet the summertime vibe is great! Especially with the outdoor seating.Dietary restrictions: Has gluten free pizza option! Yay!“

4.1 Good89 Reviews
Roma Pizza Pizza • $
17600 Red Arrow Hwy, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
PTO or Calzone
Garlic Bread

“Last time I ate here was 32 years ago when I came to visit my cousin's for the summer. It was nostalgia to the max... great tasting sauce and the crust yummy!! I've been telling my wife about it and we drove up from Chicago just to have dinner!! ??????❤️❤️ I see u guys in the summer this time with the kids!!“

3.4 Good34 Reviews
Staymaker Restaurant at Journeyman Distillery Pizza • $$
109 Generations Dr, Three Oaks

Customers` Favorites

Featherbone Bourbon Hickory BBQ Sauce 12oz
Detroit-Style Breakfast Pizza
Heritage Angus Cheese Burger
Fig Old Fashioned Cocktail
Fried Brussels Sprouts GF
Hand-Cut Seasoned Fries
House-Made Pub Pretzel
Housemade Pub Pretzel
Chicken Ceasar Salad
Whiskey Flight

“Service was amazing. We were throwing several drinks at the server and she was picking the one she thought we'd like. All the cocktails were super interesting.Food was incredible. Burger had the perfect amount of sweet and savory. French fries were perfect. Detroit style pizza was well done.All of the house liquors were great.“

4.7 Superb78 Reviews
Patellie's Pizza Takeaway • $
28 N Elm St, Three Oaks

Customers` Favorites

Whole Roasted Chicken
Build Your Own Pie
Sausage Pizza
The Meat Pie
House Salad
Margherita
Meatballs

“This place is SO good. We had a group trip from Chicago for a long weekend and got pizza here from one of the nights. We ordered a few different types and each one was delicious! I wish that it could be local for us, we would get pizza from here frequently. The service was on-point as well. It was ready when we got there and everyone was so friendly. We'll definitely order from here again in the future!“

4.7 Superb38 Reviews
Stop 50 Wood Fired Pizzeria Pizza • $
500 El Portal Dr, Michiana Shores

Customers` Favorites

Val D'Aosta Fontina & Olive Pizza
Meatballs-6 House Made Meat Balls
Sausage Pizza with Prosciutto
Seasonal Roasted Vegetables
Peppers Stuffed w Sausage
Root Vegetable Pizza
Mixed Greens Salad
Fresh Local Salad
Pizza Margherita
Seasonal Pizza

“Always our favorite place to go eat! Amazing food and fantastic people!! Stop 50 has the best service and food in the entire area!!!Vegetarian options: Absolutely perfect place for vegetarian or dietary restrictions.. staff is respectful and willing to adapt for whatever you needDietary restrictions: I'm a vegetarian and I can eat most of their menu as it's fresh made to order and they easily adapt to preferencesKid-friendliness: SUPER clean respectful and considerate to kids, good food adults and families both can enjoy!Wheelchair accessibility: Numerous and easily accessible for wheelchairs or varying disabilities!“

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
Capozio's Pizza • $
13982 Red Arrow Hwy, Harbert

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Cheese
Deep Dish Pizza
Fried Calamari
Tomato Bread
Pepperoni
Meatball
Lasagna
Sausage

“This has been our favorite pizza for over 20 years. Wife and I would go when we were dating and still go as often as we like. Still the best.Parking: Lots of parking. I think that if the parking lot is full, you ain't gonna get a seat. Lots of parking.“

4.7 Superb31 Reviews
Little Caesars Pizza Pizza • $
2026 20, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Cheese and Pepperoni
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Pizzas

“I WALKED IN AND THE CASHIER RAN BACK IN THE KITCHEN AND IT MADE ME SAD:( THEY MADE FUN OF MY CAR AND CALLED ME GAY. I AM A WORKING MOTHER OF 5 AND TRYING TO PUT FOOD ON THE TABLE. THE LITTLE AFRICAN AMERICAN GOT IN MY CAR AND STARTED SPLIFFIN ONE IN MY CAR. I GOT THE CALZONEY AND CRAZY BREAD WAS CRUSTY,MUSTY,DUSTY, AND DRY!!! MY CHILDREN DID NOT HAVE FOOD LAST THURSDAY. thanks lil seizure. not satisfiedKid-friendliness: they made my kid make my food.Wheelchair accessibility: they made fun of little timmy and forced him to walk.“

4.4 Superb29 Reviews
Featherbone Restaurant & Lounge Lounges • $
6741 US-12, Three Oaks

Customers` Favorites

Nachos Supreme
Hamburger
Pizza
Gyro

“Delicious pizza. I’m from out of town and did not expect a pie this good. Also had the bone in hot wings. I thought they were really good and also huge. They are baked not fried. I highly recommend! The wait staff was also very much on point. This place is a gem.“

4.2 Good50 Reviews
Loading...
map Map