18 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Buffalo

Roma Pizza Pizza • $
17600 Red Arrow Hwy, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Deep Dish Hawaiian Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
PTO or Calzone
Garlic Bread
Hawaiian Pie
Cheese Pizza
Meatballs

“I can't believe I've never heard of this place before! I finally stopped in and ate, and the food was AMAZING!!!!
Great taste, staff very friendly, and very spacious! Even has outdoor sitting for nice days! I give them a 10/10 and would recommend to anyone who loves pizza!!!“

4.2 Good72 Reviews
Brewster's New Buffalo Italian • $$
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Any Two Toppings Thin Crust Only
Spinach Artichoke Dip
House Salad & Soup
Charcuterie Board
House Salad Soup
Chicken Parmesan
Ice Cream Sundae
Shrimp Alfredo
Dinner for Two
Creme Brulee

“Excellent atmosphere inside and out! Excellent salads, with tender generous steak chunks and one with tender generous chicken, both with wonderful dressings! Bruschetta- amazing! Kristen and bar tender teammate were perfect! Highly recommend!“

4.5 Superb417 Reviews
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
245 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Short Rib Grilled Cheese
Veggie Burger and Fries
Southwest Egg Rolls
Fish Tacos Tilapia
Beer Battered Cod
Jalapeño Poppers
Nachos Appetizer
Jalapeno Poppers
Fish and Chips
Grilled Reuben

“I have been going to The Stray Dog for years. I have never had a bad experience there. The food is great and the service is superb! Also, if any of the ladies out there need a "personal plumber", I am available to service your unfulfilled fantasies.“

4.3 Superb551 Reviews
Villa Nova Pizzeria - New Buffalo Italian • $
134 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Italian Beef Sandwich
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Breadsticks with Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Pizza by the Slice
Buffalo Chicken
Marinara Sauce
Slice of Pizza

“Such a cute spot with amazing pizza, fried pickles and cookies. Our family enjoyed an outing to Villa Nova. Coming back soon!“

4 Good205 Reviews
Capozio's Pizza • $
13982 Red Arrow Hwy, Harbert - 7.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Cheese
Deep Dish Sicilian Pizza
Pepperoni and Pineapple
Blue Cheese Dressing
Pepperoni & Mushroom
My Meat Lover Pizza
Meatball & Sausage
Fried Mushrooms
Italian Cannoli
Minestrone Soup

“Been going for decades. Amazing family owned restaurant. Great food, pizza and pastas. The The Moon family looks forward to our return!“

4.8 Superb63 Reviews
Patellie's Pizza Takeaway • $
28 N Elm St, Three Oaks - 6.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Peppers and Onions
Whole Roasted Chicken
Build Your Own Pie
Cheese & Crackers
Sausage Sandwich
Pizzeria Salad
Sausage Pizza
The Meat Pie
House Salad
Margherita

“Crispy, crunchy, cheesy. Excellent recommendation on the sausage slice.“

4.7 Superb55 Reviews
Miller Pizza Pizza • $
1012 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City - 7.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Deep Dish Pizza with Pepperoni Sausage and Mushroom
Garlic Cheese Bread
Personal Pan Pizza
2 Slices of Pizza
Breaded Mushrooms
Pepperoni Pizza
Stuffed Pizza
Green Tomatoes
Garlic Bread
Italian Beef

“This pizza was delicious!!! I would have to say that it was the best thin crust pizza that I have ever eaten! You can taste every topping individually because of the quality ingredients! I highly recommend their pizza with the olive oil! Healthy and delicious!“

4.5 Superb50 Reviews
Staymaker Restaurant at Journeyman Distillery Pizza • $$
109 Generations Dr, Three Oaks - 6.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Featherbone Bourbon Hickory BBQ Sauce 12oz
Detroit-Style Breakfast Pizza
Heritage Angus Cheese Burger
Fig Old Fashioned Cocktail
Fried Brussels Sprouts GF
Hand-Cut Seasoned Fries
House-Made Pub Pretzel
Detroit Meets Italy V
House-Made Pretzel V
Housemade Pub Pretzel

“This was our first visit to the Staymaker, which is the restaurant within the Journeyman Distillery. We are visiting from Chicago and this was recommended and we were not disappointed! Everything was really excellent! From our charming and attentive server Hailey, to the amazing smoked trout spread app to the Trout entree and the brisket meatloaf. It was all so delicious! We will be back!“

4.4 Superb109 Reviews
Stop 50 Wood Fired Pizzeria Pizza • $
500 El Portal Dr, Michiana Shores - 4.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vegetable Pizza w Seasonal Veggies Squash and Zucchini
Val D'Aosta Fontina & Olive Pizza
Meatballs-6 House Made Meat Balls
Sausage Pizza with Prosciutto
Seasonal Roasted Vegetables
Peppers Stuffed w Sausage
Root Vegetable Pizza
Mixed Greens Salad
Fresh Local Salad
Margherita Pizza

“My absolute favorite pizza! Drive up once a month from Illinois to enjoy it!“

4.3 Superb79 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
1701 Greenwood Ave, Michigan City - 9.25 miles

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Little Giant Pizza at the beach Pizza Delivery • $$
2418 St Lawrence Ave, Long Beach - 6.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Pig Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Deluxe Pizza

“Delicious St Louis style pizza! It definitely did not disappoint my family during our recent reunion meal. Great pizza in every meaning of the word! Perfect toppings, excellent app for ordering and great service too. Great choice! We'll be back.“

4.3 Superb14 Reviews
Cravin's To Order Pizza Takeaway •
4593 US-20, Rolling Prairie - 10.53 miles

“It might be in a gas station but this pizza we ordered online and picked up was delicious! We bought the BBQ chicken with extra bacon and cheese. Definitely will buy again and grab some for lunch in between my jobs!*We bought an xl pizza with extra bacon and cheese and it was about 15! We had leftovers for a couple days!

Parking: It's a gas station, plenty of room to park!“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Pizza Hut Express Pizza • $
Travel Centers Of America, 6100 Sawyer Rd, Sawyer - 9.71 miles
4 Good7 Reviews
Little Caesars Pizza Pizza • $
2026 US-20, Michigan City - 9.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Dough Brownie Made with M&M’S Minis Chocol
Hot and Ready Pepperoni Pizza Pepperoni
Crazy Combo Crazy Bread & Crazy Sauce
Thin Crust Cheese and Pepperoni
Detroit-Style Deep Dish Sausage
Custom Detroit-Style Deep Dish
Crazy Puffs Crazy Sauce Combo
3 Cheese and Herb Crazy Puffs
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Extramostbestest Pepperoni

“The best in town“

3.9 Good49 Reviews
Mario’s Pizza Union pier Italian • $
Red Arrow Hwy #16170, Union Pier - 3.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Combo - Italian Beef & Italian Sausage
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
House Special Pizza
Philly Cheese Steak
Large House Salad
Sausage Calzone
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Meatball

“Really good food, super nice people“

4.6 Superb58 Reviews
Featherbone Restaurant & Lounge Lounges • $
6741 US-12, Three Oaks - 6.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Nachos Supreme
Hamburger
Gyro

“Our experiences at Feather Bone have been great - food, service, cool local vibe. Sports always on the TVs which is a nice bonus! Prices are very reasonable too.“

4.4 Superb47 Reviews
Shady Creek Winery Wineries • $$
2030 Tryon Rd, Michigan City - 6.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Group Package - Charcuterie
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Thin Crust Pizza
Charcuterie Plate
Goat Cheese Dip
Meat Lover's
Wine Flight
Baked Brie
Sandwich
Dry Red

“Great place for meeting up with friends and enjoying wine time. The food is good… we ordered two flatbreads and both were good (Thai chili & jerk chicken). The burger was cool. However. We didn’t really care for the short rib sandwich.
The menu is small but I love that they use all types of flavors. The atmosphere is beautiful with nice views and they have outdoor pods you can rent for your group. Check it out! Nice spot :)“

4.3 Superb121 Reviews
Albano's Pizza Inc Pizza • $
6492 W Johnson Rd, La Porte - 10.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Albano's Masterpiece Pizza
Italian Beef

“The people working here are great and were very friendly providing excellent service. The pizza we order was very good served hot. The only negative was the house salad which consisted of lettuce and a slice of tomato. I expected a little more in regard to a salad mix (olive, mushrooms, cheese, shredded carrots, bacon bits, etc.).“

3.2 Average20 Reviews

You May Also Like