What are you looking for?

Pizza Restaurants in Michigan City

4.4 - 180 votes

Hours: 11AM - 1:30AM

1714 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 874-3663

Papa Johns Pizza

I order every time I’m in town, this is normally a great pizza. Not sure what’s going on with the kitchen or the service. Ordered a ground beef pizza, go... More reviews

4.1 - 150 votes

3515 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 873-9262

Papa Johns Pizza

My boyfriend and I came to town for a little weekend getaway and we got to the hotel a little late. We were starving and really wanted some authentic piz... More reviews

4 - 187 votes

Hours: 4 - 10

1612 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-0571

Papa Johns Pizza

We ordered a lg taco pizza with lettuce on the side, a lg sausage and mush and a 6 pc cheese bread. The taco pizza was ok but it only had tomato and meat... More reviews

4 - 154 votes

Hours: 11AM - 8:30PM

1012 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City
(219) 878-9480

Papa Johns Pizza

Miller Pizza is a constant go to for their thin crust pizza! Their pizza is as good as any place in Chicago!Vegetarian options: They have many vegetarian... More reviews

4.3 - 32 votes

Hours: Closed today

811 Lighthouse Pl, Michigan City
(219) 262-5188

Papa Johns Pizza

Wait 45 minutes for some small pizzas I mean it taste great but the customer service is horrible never see me again More reviews

3.8 - 139 votes

Hours: Closed today

2400 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-9123

Papa Johns Pizza

Trying to fine a good pizza in this town. Saw their sign and decided to give them a try. Best decision I ever made. Their pizza is delicious! I had been ... More reviews

3.8 - 125 votes

Hours: 11AM - 3AM

1729 US-20, Michigan City
(219) 878-9556

Papa Johns Pizza

Horrible food and over priced. Staff is rude as can be. Second time eating here and I am sick, AGAIN. If I could give 0 stars, I would. The kitchen staff... More reviews

3.8 - 93 votes

2026 20, Michigan City
(219) 879-3211

Papa Johns Pizza

Tried their new Detroit style Deep dish pizza. Crispy crust. Plenty of cheese and pepperoni. Great flavor. Has a completely different taste than their re... More reviews

3.7 - 170 votes

5184 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-3838

Papa Johns Pizza

Michigan City location... We Ordered buffalo bread and expected more than 4 small slices for $9.00. Two of the slices were burnt. More reviews

3.3 - 71 votes

3229 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-7227

Papa Johns Pizza

Order was as expected tasty and great will be going here again and very nice workers. More reviews

View on map