What are you looking for?

Pizza Restaurants in Michigan City

4.4 - 184 votes

Hours: 11AM - 1:30AM

1714 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 874-3663

Papa Johns Pizza

This bar is the place to go if your looking for a great night out with amazing bartenders, great food and they even have karaoke on Tuesday and Thursday ... More reviews

4.1 - 155 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 11PM

3515 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 873-9262

Papa Johns Pizza

Great looking pizzas, solid deals, and energetic staff. Especially considering there's quite a few other pizza places in the area. Calzones look inc... More reviews

4 - 189 votes

Hours: 4 - 10PM

1612 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-0571

Papa Johns Pizza

Albano's is the absolute best tavern style pizza anywhere outside of Chicago. Crispy crust and lots of cheese. Dough, sauce and even the sausage is ... More reviews

4 - 157 votes

Hours: 11AM - 8:30PM

1012 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City
(219) 878-9480

Papa Johns Pizza

Worst Chicago Pizza I Ever Had..Pizza seemed a little cold and bland..Wings were Aldi wings seemed like to me just thrown in the oven no sauce on them.. ... More reviews

4.4 - 31 votes

Hours: 12 - 5PM

811 Lighthouse Pl, Michigan City
(219) 262-5188

Papa Johns Pizza

Excellent pizza, perfect to share for only 15 euro! Lovely beer and very reasonable prices. Free cold water which we loved. Thank you! More reviews

3.9 - 139 votes

Hours: 4PM - 12AM

2400 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-9123

Papa Johns Pizza

This is definitely the best pizza in Michigan City. Most things are made from scratch and absolutely delicious! More reviews

3.7 - 91 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

2026 20, Michigan City
(219) 879-3211

Papa Johns Pizza

Grabbed a hot and ready... It was hot and ready and delicious. I was in and out in no time.Food: 5/5 More reviews

3.7 - 173 votes

Hours: 11AM - 11PM

5184 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-3838

Papa Johns Pizza

Kelly was our server and she is TOP NOTCH!!! The Italian beef was out of this world as was the Popeye! Will DEFINITELY be back! More reviews

3.5 - 90 votes

Hours: 11AM - 11PM

1608 E Michigan Blvd, Michigan City
(219) 872-1616

Papa Johns Pizza

Three weekends in a row and nobody answers the phone. Very poorly ran establishment. If I was the owner of this place I would be very upset. How do you d... More reviews

3.3 - 71 votes

Hours: 10AM - 1AM

3229 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-7227

Papa Johns Pizza

Order was as expected tasty and great will be going here again and very nice workers. More reviews

View on map