25 Best Pizza Restaurants in Valparaiso

“Always a great experience dining in or carrying out. Love how fresh and delicious the ingredients are. From starters, to salad, wraps, calzones, or pizza. We’re always happy with whatever we get and it’s such a fun place to bring our kids too. Love the beer options as well. Thanks for making us happy customers.“

“great food and service. Fire grilled mushrooms rocked“

“fast service and cheap good food“

“The pizza is literally the best pizza in the area!“

“Food staff and owner amazing Best wings in VALPO in my opinion Pizza and appetizers are fantastic“

“We have used them for several parties. I usually call my order in early and ask to have it delivered at a certain time and it is always delivered on time. We love the pizza and wings and always get compliments on how good the food is at the party! Highly recommend!“

“Great wings, cold drinks, hot staff, what more could you want??“

“Not only was the restaurant atmosphere lovely but the food was simply delicious, the portions more than generous and our waitress was pleasant and helpful!!!“

“Possibly the best pizza in Valpo and the crew is always so kind and courteous! The Detroit style and hand-tossed are both fantastic, loaded with toppings and everything on the menu is extremely reasonably priced! Order this up for dinner tonight, you’ll love it! 🍕“

“Meatballs are the best I’ve ever had and desserts are amazing. Best servers in the area. Can’t wait to try the box lunch, my favorite from Dish.“

“Tonight me, my fiance and little sister went to Zao Island and went on the GoKarts. We did all the laps and got called back in. While us three were stopped ready to get out, I heard a mom say “slow down” and her child drove into the back of my cart, didn’t brake at all and I hit my head so hard on the back of my seat. To the mom, you and your little boy are not at fault at all! The workers should’ve said slow down or show them how to brake beforehand. They didn’t even check if any of us were okay afterwards. I think there needs to be an age restriction on the GoKarts or at least a mandatory demonstration for the little ones before they drive. I absolutely love Zao and mean no harm but the workers for the GoKarts needed to handle the situation better for the future. 🫶🏻“

“The pizza had a perfect crust—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The toppings were fresh and generous, making each bite delicious. The atmosphere was relaxed, and the staff were friendly and welcoming. If you're looking for a great pizza place in Valparaiso, Uncle Menny's is definitely worth checking out!“

“We’ve been long term patrons of peddlers for their pizzas. Their cracker crusts are amazing if you like thin crust pizzas. They also have gluten free cauliflower crusts that are delicious. However, finally leaving a public review after the outstanding experience with their private room, Sidebar. The manager and bartender that helped for the event were absolutely wonderful, and overall if you’re looking for a low key event space in Valpo that doesn’t cause you to sell a kidney to pay for it or sign a 16 page contract to book it this is your place. Can’t say enough great things about our experience this weekend. A huge thanks to your team again for helping us pull off the surprise!“

“Had wrote a review a few days ago regarding a coupon not being utilized for a 50% off. I just deleted the review on accident but wanted to update to anyone who had read that. A manager contacted me and apologized for the mistake that had been made. The young man that had taken the order was fairly new and has now been educated on how to process that particular type of coupon. Managment was extremely apologetic and quick to recover and make me feel much better about the situation. They offered a credit for the WHOLE pizza!!! We well absolutely order from Rosati‘s again as that is our favorite pizza and the closest to Chicago as we can get in pizza.“

“Today, July 18th, we had my grandson's birthday party at Gelsosomo's Pizzeria Valparaiso, there was 15 of us there & our server Tabitha was awesome! She did an outstanding job! The pizzas were amazing! I highly recommend Gelsosemo’s Pizzeria Valparaiso!“

“Tonight me, my fiance and little sister went to Zao Island and went on the GoKarts. We did all the laps and got called back in. While us three were stopped ready to get out, I heard a mom say “slow down” and her child drove into the back of my cart, didn’t brake at all and I hit my head so hard on the back of my seat. To the mom, you and your little boy are not at fault at all! The workers should’ve said slow down or show them how to brake beforehand. They didn’t even check if any of us were okay afterwards. I think there needs to be an age restriction on the GoKarts or at least a mandatory demonstration for the little ones before they drive. I absolutely love Zao and mean no harm but the workers for the GoKarts needed to handle the situation better for the future. 🫶🏻“

“Everything is always spot on and delicious! I do take it home, 20 miles away. I hope someone reads these cause I got to tell you, one time I got my chicago dog with everything, wrapped in a brown parchment? and then the foil and it was the best. Not soggy and everything was crisp. Of course don't sleep on a rainbow cone cookie either. Thank you Buona!“

“There someone who works at this Casey’s named Zach. He was a very respectful young man and the other people working there were as well. I was hoping that this review could possibly get them in a better position than what he’s at right now or a raise. I’m not the type of person to write reviews, but Zach was such a respectful person so I had the need to write a review.“

“Food stayed warm after a 30+ minute traffic hellscape. Tastes like the pizza joints that used to be around my neighborhood when I was a kid. Wings excellent,if you like saucy wings get a side of sauce. If not theyre seasoned perfectly.

If you like pinball machines they have quite a collection. Manager was training new employee while I was there and they were doing an excellent job,kudos to you.

Overall a guilty pleasure.“

“so yummyyyy i love their pizza😃😜“

“Chicago style that makes a great party dish.“

“Great service from employees, pizza and wings are also delicious! Will come back.“

“Well everyone always tells me if you have bad service once you should always try again. Well I did and guess what service was still bad. With only 9 people in the bar area we asked for menus and drinks. We got the drinks but the bartender was too busy on her phone to come back and take our order. After waiting almost 30 minutes I walked out. I use to go there at least three times a week. Never again.“

“Papa John's is decent for cheap pizza. The crust is pretty decent, good fresh mushrooms, never enough cheese or toppings for me. Compared to dominos? this pizza is fantastic, compared to Manny's Greeks? Well Greeks wins every time! But it's cheap and they have a great rewards program! So if you want cheap and decent, this is it!

Kid-friendliness: Kids love the cheese stuffed crust and they will even stuff the pepperoni in the crust?“

“I have ordered many times from this Little Ceasars and have always been satisfied with the flavor and freshness of their food“