12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Three Oaks

“This was our first visit to the Staymaker, which is the restaurant within the Journeyman Distillery. We are visiting from Chicago and this was recommended and we were not disappointed! Everything was really excellent! From our charming and attentive server Hailey, to the amazing smoked trout spread app to the Trout entree and the brisket meatloaf. It was all so delicious! We will be back!“

“Had a lovely meal tonight at Featherbone - Chef had a weekend special I saw online and he had one left tonight when I came in. Every bite was perfection! Thanks for the treat! Watch out folks- if you see the ribeye special again go for it!!!!“

“Excellent atmosphere inside and out! Excellent salads, with tender generous steak chunks and one with tender generous chicken, both with wonderful dressings! Bruschetta- amazing! Kristen and bar tender teammate were perfect! Highly recommend!“

“I have been going to The Stray Dog for years. I have never had a bad experience there. The food is great and the service is superb! Also, if any of the ladies out there need a "personal plumber", I am available to service your unfulfilled fantasies.“

“We walked into Roma’s during a pretty big rush and, unfortunately, misunderstood the situation and thought they weren’t taking any more orders. We went back out to our car, and the owner actually made a point to come outside, find us, and clarify that they were absolutely still taking orders and that we were welcome to stay and eat in the dining room. That alone really stood out to us.

He was so incredibly attentive and kind throughout our visit. He even gave our daughter a complimentary bracelet and a scoop of ice cream, which absolutely made her day. 🤍

And the pizza… WOW. Some of the best pizza we’ve ever had. The sauce was PHENOMENAL. We loved it so much that we even ordered extra sauce on the side to dip our pizza in. He told us it was his family’s recipe from Italy and that their family has been making pizza since the 1960s. You could truly taste the history and care behind it.

What really made the experience special was how clearly family-owned and personal the restaurant felt. We didn’t even realize the person who had gone out of his way to make sure we were taken care of was the owner until we asked at the end!

My husband literally said, “I wish we had a place like this back home.”

If you’re in New Buffalo, GO HERE. The pizza is incredible, the sauce is unforgettable, and the hospitality is the kind you don’t come across often anymore. We were genuinely blown away and will absolutely be back! 🍕❤“

“Really good food, super nice people“

“It might be in a gas station but this pizza we ordered online and picked up was delicious! We bought the BBQ chicken with extra bacon and cheese. Definitely will buy again and grab some for lunch in between my jobs!*We bought an xl pizza with extra bacon and cheese and it was about 15! We had leftovers for a couple days!

Parking: It's a gas station, plenty of room to park!“

“Thank you so much for making my birthday dinner great. I originally wanted Italian beef but you were sold out so I ordered the shrimp dinner. it was fantastic! We love everything we get from you but tonight's dinner was great!“

“the pizza is outstanding! I would eat it everyday if I lived closer. the staff is always wonderful. it's always on the list of places to go when I'm in town“

“First time there last night - plan on returning ! The waitress was very attentive, patient and all around great ! The food was good , the atmosphere is small home town - there was 4 of us , we all got different entries and enjoyed them very much. Portion sizes are big ! We will be back to try the pretzel that covered a large plate ! Another table ordered it as we were eating our main entrees but it looked amazing“

“Great pizza. Best in town. Family owned business for as long as I can remeber. Really can't go wrong with anything ordered here. Great bartenders. Definitely a go to spot in town for lunch or dinner.“