Brewster's New Buffalo
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-3005
Customers' Favorites
Pizza with Any Two Toppings Thin Crust Only
Spinach Artichoke Dip
House Salad & Soup
Charcuterie Board
House Salad Soup
Chicken Parmesan
Ice Cream Sundae
Shrimp Alfredo
Dinner for Two
Creme Brulee
Menu
Photos
+86 photos
+85 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Delicious food. I've gone twice now and we had great friendly service both times. Once for brunch which was amazing and the other for dinner, also wonderful. It's a really nice restaurant inside and out. Huge portions, very reasonably priced and really tasty. You will need a to go box unless you are really hungry. You cant beat the dinner for two for 65 bucks. You get a lot of food and get to try a few things. Its a great deal. I loved the olives and feta appetizer,...
Love this beautiful restaurant. We have eaten both inside and outside and both times we enjoyed the service, delicious food, and beautiful atmosphere. It’s located close to a pleasant walk to the beach. We enjoyed some delicious mocktails before getting our meals and were gifted cookies for dessert in honor of our anniversary. I would recommend booking a reservation to avoid a long wait.
Experience and food was incredible! Our waitress was Morghyn and she went above and beyond to make the experience amazing for our birthdays. She is so kind, helpful with options, and displays exemplary customer service. We ordered a pasta with short rib, pizza, tuna appetizer, and a few other goodies. Staff and overall ambiance was welcoming and relaxed. One of the best meals we’ve had, but Brewster’s never misses anyway!
You May Also Like
David's Delicatessen & Coffee - 30 N Whittaker St
![]()
Deli, Coffee & Tea, Cafe, American, Vegan
Sonny D's Bar & Grill - 1 N Whittaker St
![]()
American, Bar, Seafood
The Original Rainbow Cone - 1 N Whittaker St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream