Brewster's New Buffalo
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-3005
Customers' Favorites
Pizza with Any Two Toppings Thin Crust Only
Spinach Artichoke Dip
House Salad & Soup
Charcuterie Board
House Salad Soup
Chicken Parmesan
Ice Cream Sundae
Shrimp Alfredo
Dinner for Two
Creme Brulee
Menu
Photos
+86 photos
+85 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
My husband and I love coming here! The pizza is amazing. Their coffee is so good!! The atmosphere is really, really nice and relaxing. We sat outside tonight on the “new balcony” We normally request our favorite Waitress ♥️MORGAN but tonight we weren’t able to see her because she was serving inside. So we got a new waitress, Her name is AVA, She said she just recently started working here and she is one of the best waitresses we’ve had besides Morgan! Both girls energy...
It was lunchtime and busy. Taking that into account, our experience with Amanda was the best it could be.
I wasn't a fan of the arugula salad greens... regular lettuce would have sufficed.
Other than that, everything was delicious.
I wasn't a fan of the arugula salad greens... regular lettuce would have sufficed.
Other than that, everything was delicious.
Brewster’s is THE spot to eat in New Buffalo. We have been many times for birthdays and anniversaries. Our favorite is their 2 for $65, which comes with soup or salad, pizza, an entree, and a warm cookie with coffee. Such an amazing deal with exquisite food. By far our favorite dish is the short rib & hummus. I’ve never tasted anything like it - it’s better than a meal in Vegas! The drinks are just as phenomenal. Anything you get here will be perfect and we highly recommend...
You May Also Like
David's Delicatessen & Coffee - 30 N Whittaker St
![]()
Deli, Coffee & Tea, Cafe, American, Vegan
Sonny D's Bar & Grill - 1 N Whittaker St
![]()
American, Bar, Seafood
The Original Rainbow Cone - 1 N Whittaker St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop