9 Best American Restaurants in New Buffalo

Copper Rock Steakhouse New Buffalo American • $$$
11111 Wilson Rd, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Filet Mignon Mushrooms Mashed Potatoes
55 Day Dry Aged 26 Oz Bone-In Ribeye
Bread Basket and Spread Assortment
Assortment of Cheese Spreads
Jumbo Whole Maine Lobster
Shrimp and Lobster Pasta
Cajun Salmon Fillet
Oyster Rockefeller
Chocolate Beignets
French Onion Soup

“Celebrated wife's birthday. We both had the special - French Onion Soup(delicious), the 7oz Filets, potato & veggie, and creme brulee for $60. The soup is probably the best French Onion I've had. I'm not a big filet person but it was seasoned & Cooked perfectly. The creme brulee dessert is delicious. Service was spot on. Our waitress was on top of everything and didn't miss a beat. We've been to copper rock several times in South Bend. New Buffalo's blew them out of the water.“

4.6 Superb316 Reviews
Oink's Dutch Treat Ice Cream Shop • $
227 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Mint Chocolate Ice Cream Cone
Lemon Cheesecake Ice Cream
Blackberry Ice Cream Cone
Banana Pudding Ice Cream

“We checked this place out on our way through New Buffalo. Service was great and very friendly! I had the blackberry and the lemon cheesecake. My partner had the Carmel and banana cream pie. All of the flavors were excellent. The interior of the space was fun and full of memorabilia. There were spots around the parking lot to take pictures and relax.Dietary restrictions: They have some vegan optionsKid-friendliness: Kids would love this place“

4.6 Superb96 Reviews
David's Delicatessen & Coffee Deli • $
30 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Reuben Sandwich
Build Your Own Sandwich
Everything Bagel with
Vegan Sandwich
Cinnamon Roll
Pastries
Build

“The best build your own bagel sandwich and oatmilk cortado I've had in a long time! My husband, our friends and I were vacationing in New Buff for the New Year's weekend and came to David's for breakfast and were blown away, not only by their food and drinks but their excellent service! They also have amazing lunch and pastry options! You've got to visit and experience it for yourself, can't recommend them more!Vegetarian options: Can build your own sandwiches without meat and their lunch options are very vegetarian friendly!“

4.7 Superb63 Reviews
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
245 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Short Rib Grilled Cheese
Southwest Egg Rolls
Fish Tacos Tilapia
Beer Battered Cod
Nachos Appetizer
Shrimp Tacos
Cheese Curds
Chicken Wings
Sandwiches
Mahi Tacos

“Passing the signs on the freeway for this place for a long time finally got a chance to stop in. Food was actually pleasantly good. Service was good food came out pretty quick very tasty.Place very clean atmosphere good.Will stop by there again. Everything is extra so if you get a burger or a sandwich to the fries or onion rings are an extra charge. !! And for the dollar value I would get the onion rings they're in a bigger basket the fries for the money you don't get that much“

4.4 Superb198 Reviews
Skip's Restaurant and Catering American • $$
16710 Lakeshore Rd, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Prime Rib and Seafood Combination
Black and Bleu Pasta
Vegetable of the Day
Loaded Baked Potato
Mozzarella Sticks
French Onion Soup
Dessert Table
Lake Perch
Walleye
Salads

“Skips is a blast from the past and in the best way. The interior has an old school supper club vibe - dropped ceiling, fireplace, big tables and a cozy bar. The staff is super friendly and knowledgeable of the menu. The food was amazing - everyone in our party enjoyed their meal. Skips has been around for 50 yrs and it is clear why - they execute on everything well.“

4.4 Superb64 Reviews
New Buffalo Yacht Club American • $$
500 W Water St, New Buffalo

“My husband Scott (The Detail Guy) and I love being new members this year. It’s been our go-to place to connect with new friends in the area since our move here two years ago, bring family over for some waterfront views, and entertain guests who visit.Ryan and team are wonderful. We love the views, watching games, and can’t wait for more events in the months ahead.“

4.9 Superb7 Reviews
Casey's New Buffalo Bar & Grill • $
136 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Mac and Cheese with BBQ Pulled Pork
Great Craft Beer Selection
Side Sweet Potato Tots
Maryland Crab Cakes
Boom Boom Shrimp
Fish and Chips
Perch Sandwich
Truffle Fries
Cheese Curds
Fish Tacos

“We really loved our meal! We split the rib sandwich and the blackberry burger. Wow wish I had my own burger. Truffle fries were great, ordered them extra crispy too! Tried a side of fried cod and that was good too but kinda soggy by the time I ate it back at the hotel (takeout). Also tried the Sweet potato tots. If I go again I'm going straight for the blackberry burger and sweet potato tots.“

3.9 Good83 Reviews
Bentwood Tavern American • $$$
600 W Water St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Sweet Potato
Skuna Bay Salmon
Southwest Salad
Margarita Smoky
House Beignets
Tavern Burger
Fish & Chips
Shrimp Tacos
Fish Tacos
Octopus

“Stumbled into this place on our adventure to see the sunset over Lake Michigan. Glad we did! It was our family of five, kids had a great hamburger and fish and chips. Started off with some fantastic sourdough and grass-fed butter along with some very well prepared calamari. I had the spare rib ragú which was phenomenal but, I must say my wife’s white fish was AMAZING! The smell alone of the capers and tomatoes was enough to make your mouth water. Very nicely done!“

3.8 Good68 Reviews
Sonny D's Bar & Grill American • $$
1 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Ida’S Loaded Potato Cakes
Blackened Chicken Sandwich
Homemade Carrot Cake
Bavarian Pretzels
Chicken Parmigiana
California Burger
Caprese Salad
Flatbread
Sonny

“The place was nice and had an overall laidback relaxing vibe. The menu was diverse and prices seemed fair for what was given. Portion sizes were big, and I loved the skin on fries. The only problem I had was with the services. Our waitress seemed to forget about us, and the place didn’t seem that busy. But she was nice.“

3.8 Good114 Reviews
Loading...
map Map