What are you looking for?

American Restaurants in New Buffalo

4.5 - 750 votes

Hours: Closed today

11111 Wilson Rd, New Buffalo
(866) 494-6371

Papa Johns Pizza

They raised their prices, but the 3 course meal special is good. However, we both ordered the 7oz filet, and their was quite a difference in the size of ... More reviews

4.5 - 256 votes

Hours: Closed today

16710 Lakeshore Rd, New Buffalo
(269) 469-3330

Papa Johns Pizza

Nice place had a good filet and scallops. Wife enjoyed the Alfredo pasta. Martinis where perfect.Food: 5/5 More reviews

4.4 - 340 votes

Hours: 5 - 10PM

600 W Water St, New Buffalo
(866) 238-2208

Papa Johns Pizza

Brentwood has a beautiful decor. The outdoor dining next to the marina offers serene views. The food was delicious, albeit quite pricey. More reviews

4.3 - 448 votes

Hours: 12 - 11PM

245 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-2727

Papa Johns Pizza

Been here several times and it's way overrated! Went for my birthday and the unfriendly hostess began taking us back to the afterthought add on room... More reviews

4.8 - 16 votes

Hours: 3 - 9PM

500 W Water St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-9808

Papa Johns Pizza

Great place, great people, food is always good. The perch dinners were really good.What a nice evening out with friends. More reviews

4 - 631 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

11111 Wilson Rd, New Buffalo
(866) 494-6371

Papa Johns Pizza

This place is inside four winds casino. After playing the one armed bandit (slots) we decided to have a bite to eat. The veggie wrap was so amazing that ... More reviews

3.6 - 102 votes

Hours: 8AM - 10PM

11111 Wilson Rd, New Buffalo
(866) 494-6371

Papa Johns Pizza

We ate here for a late night dinner because it was all that was open. It was good but more like fast food. The service was very slow but the staff was go... More reviews

3.8 - 300 votes

Hours: 12PM - 12AM

136 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-6400

Papa Johns Pizza

Food was awesome! Our waitress Chianna did a fantastic job! We will go back soon! The appetizer was SO good!!Food: 5/5 More reviews

3.1 - 113 votes

Hours: Closed today

11111 Wilson Rd, New Buffalo
(866) 494-6371

Papa Johns Pizza

Omg... we ate one course.. asked were our drinks were.. hostess said be right back with them... after the second course I asked if there was a water stat... More reviews

Loading...
View on map