$ • Fast Food, Hot Dogs, Ice Cream, Frozen Yogurt

142 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-4240


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Nancy's

Been here a couple times now that Oinks doesn't serve Sherman's anymore. Nancy's sells hudsonville ice cream, which I have been quit pleased with. The portions are decent and they have a nice little outdoor seating area too.

Nancy’s is a definite highlight of my trip to michigan. Tons of ice cream flavors to choose from, and all of them delicious!! portion sizes were perfect and the price was reasonable. the staff was also beyond friendly, and provided great customer service. 10/10 ice cream, and i will be going back to nancy’s every time i’m in new buffalo!

My friend and I stopped here on our way back from swimming at Warren Dunes all day, and this was SO good. We wanted fries and shakes and this came up first in the search (we’re not local.) All the staff are incredibly friendly and the food came out quickly and fresh and hot. The milkshakes are also so good. Bonus points for the cute outdoor tables and quaint small town vibe. 10/10 recommend, hope to visit again soon!!

More Reviews(95)


Monday 12 - 9:30PM
Tuesday 12 - 9:30PM
Wednesday 12 - 9:30PM
Thursday Closed
Friday 12 - 10PM
Saturday 12 - 10PM
Sunday 12 - 9:30PM