4 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newberry

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ we visited Seders Pizza last week while in the area snowmobiling. We ordered calzones and quickly noticed as they arrived to our table that 2 people would not be able to finish 2 calzones! So we ate 1 and boxed 1 up to take back to the hotel and likely home to eat later but our calzones were so dang good that we decided to return to Seders the next and final night of our stay in newberry to get one more calzone fresh cooked to share at the restaurant AND we brought our leftover back home. The calzones are amazing and would be worth the trip all way to newberry from Green Bay to have another one! We were able to reheat our leftover calzone in the air fryer at home and it was almost as good as fresh! Excellent food and very cozy restaurant with great service!“

“Can't believe this place is still open! Must be great pizza still lol. I've been gone from that town for many yrs and used to order their pizza a lot, when I was living there. GREAT RECIPES PIZZA PLACE 😁!!!“

“Best club sandwich I’ve ever had , and I didn’t even want a sandwich at the time . I plan on coming through at least once a winter ! Next time I need a t shirt“

“On 3/7 I went to Pizza Hut for lunch. I use a wheelchair and after the renovations at the front door the sill is too high, so I went around to try the back door. The waitress came out Immediately and had someone move a car out of my way then proceeded to chop ice so I could make it in. Unbelievable and exceptional . She was outstanding also as she served the table. She anticipated what we needed and it was there. Sorry I didn't get her name she's a treasure.“