11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Petoskey

“What a happy find!! We arrived to our hotel to tired to go out to eat. Came across Mighty Fine Pizza when searching delivery options. The pizza was outstanding. Wings were meaty and their rub n sauce delicious. Don't skip ordering their Might Fine Salad- definitely add one to your order. Everything was delivered hot and fresh. Staff very pleasant. I only wish they were in my hometown.“

“We just moved to Petoskey and had or first, but won’t be our last, experience here. The place is great! The pizza was delicious. Our waitress was excellent. She was friendly and attentive. We will be back“

“Great pizza the staff and owner are very friendly 10/10 would recommend“

“Everything we ordered was great. The pizza was awesome as was the cheese bread and the chicken tenders. I was talking to the owners and this is all new ownership and a whole new location than the old one. We will definitely be ordering from them again!“

“Best eggs Benedict Petoskey has to offer. I’ve tried them all.“

“Great food and great service what else can you ask for. They have delicious salads pizzas and grinders. Their staff is always very nice. Service is prompt. I highly recommend if you're looking for a great food and great service!!
.“

“Their pizza has really been on point lately tonight my boyfriend ordered himself a pizza and I got pasta due to my tooth being pulled today. All was warm and delicious. The person behind the counter who handed us our food took the time to show us the meals and make sure they were up to expectations and was very kind. I think I will pay more in person too being that it is so much cheaper to pay in cash than online.“

“Ordered a small square pizza. Cheese and other toppings were great! Cheese had good flavor and just enough pull to it. The sauce was bright and fresh, although a bit too heavy. The middle of the pizza was much thinner then the edges and flopped, which caused a bunch of sauce to fall off it. But all the flavors were good. Would give it a second go.“

“Placed and order for delivery and my food did take a little longer to get here. I called the store and was told only one driver was on and would have my food soon. And it did arrive soon and was delicious! Kudos to the man running food by himself and delivering it hot and correctly. Doesn’t even matter it took longer. Thank you!“

“The chairs are super uncomfortable if you plan to eat here, but the girl who ordered our food was impressive. Gave amazing customer service. Our food was hot and ready to go with no wait even though we didn't order ahead and ordered odd ball things. The price was really great for the amount of food we got!“