Pizza Restaurants in Petoskey

Mighty Fine Pizza Pizza • $
222 E Mitchell St, Petoskey

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Burgers and More
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Caesar
Bread Sticks
Mighty Fine
Fine Pizza
Sauce
BBQ

“We are from out of town but love to patronage local business. We ordered a deep dish pizza from this mom/pop business and it by far was one of the best we've had. You won't be disappointed ordering from here. It is not your run of the mill pizza. Great phone staff and delivery person!“

4.4 Superb72 Reviews
Duffys Garage & Grille Pizza • $
317 E Lake St, Petoskey

Customers` Favorites

Steak and Cheese Grinder
Stuffed Mushroom Caps
The Landfill Pizza
Della Donna Pizza
Stuffed Mushrooms
Hot Honey Pizza
Steak Sandwich
Caprese Pizza
Philly Steak
Bruschetta

“All though the food was delicious! It all came out hot and as ordered. Our service was a little iffy this visit. She came to the table carring a pitcher of water and a glass of beer. Instead of serving the glass of beer 1st she tried pouring water first. This caused her to spill beer on my husband's jacket. She offered towels but we never got them.Dietary restrictions: Maybe adding some diabetic friendly options.Kid-friendliness: Great kids menu.“

4.2 Good99 Reviews
Sam’s Graces Cafe Bakery • $
324 E Mitchell St, Petoskey

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Whitefish Benedict
Fennel Sausage & Peppers
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Grilled Cheese & Soup
Roasted Beet & Chevre
Homemade Hashbrowns
Buttermilk Pancakes
Mixed Green Salad
Mushroom Frittata
Greek Frittata

“Best pizza ever! I can't eat pizza because I thought I had celiacs disease. It turns out I do not. I just can only eat the best quality flour. I don't have digestive issues when I eat at Sam's Grace's. Thank you, Sam's graces!“

4.1 Good72 Reviews
Iron Horse Cafe - NCMC Soup •
1515 Howard St, Petoskey
5 Superb2 Reviews
Pizza Ranchini Pizza • $
315 W Mitchell St, Petoskey

“This tiny pizzeria would be missed had we not known the address. We were in the downtown area and wanted to try the pizza, knowing we would be brining it back to our place to eat. I walked in, just enough room for myself, and ordered the pizza directly with the staff. I was informed about a 20 minute wait. We walked more and picked up the pizza 20 minutes later. Can I say it was honestly the BEST pizza I have ever eaten! They were very generous with the topping, all so fresh, but the crust.... no words! It was pricey, but so worth it! WE ordered two large pizzas for two people. Each hate half one day, half the other, so price breakdown, it's cheaper than two dinners at a restaurant.“

3.7 Good3 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza • $$
302 W Mitchell St, Petoskey

Customers` Favorites

All Meaty Deep Dish Duo
Large Aloha BBQ Chicken
Antipasto Salad
Wings
Jet

“Jet's never disappoints, but this location is next level in terms of service and quality of food. I watched the pizza being prepared and cooked and then immediately handed over to me. This location is super busy, but the staff are top notch!“

3.7 Good46 Reviews
Mancino's of Petoskey Pizza • $
109 W Mitchell St, Petoskey

Customers` Favorites

1 2 Pepperoni 1 2 Sausage Pizza
Cowboy Chicken Grinder
Spicy Italian Grinder
Chicken Parm Grinder
Stromboli Grinder
Thin Crust Pizza
Steak Grinder

“Pizza shop with extensive menu. Kid friendly with dine-in options. Hard working staff hustled to complete our order in a timely manner. Tasty!Parking: Plenty of spaces in front and the side of the building.Kid-friendliness: Video games and air hockey while you wait.“

3.5 Good55 Reviews
B.C. Pizza Petoskey Pizza • $
910 Spring St #6, Petoskey

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Fried Mushrooms
Chicken Wings
Salad Bar

“They always strive for perfection! Of all the locations of bc pizza this one will always be my favorite. I wish we could help get them a new oven so they could keep up with demand!Vegetarian options: There's a variety of sauces, toppings, even cauliflower and gluten free crust!Parking: Right off the main drag in the Bay Mall strip, there's was whole parking lot.Kid-friendliness: They have a crane game and coin operated vending machines!Wheelchair accessibility: There's a ramp near the entrance“

3.4 Good58 Reviews
Corktown Pizza Pizza • $
1965 Waabizhish Drive (Marten) B, Petoskey

Customers` Favorites

Square Detroit Style Cheese Pizza
Motown Meat Lover Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“Pleasantly surprised! Not a fan of Detroit style pizza, but THIS pizza was delicious!! Crispy corners and the sauce is to die for. The sauce is served on top of the pizza, which is an unusual twist, but worth it. Also the Italian sub was delicious. The sub roll was toasted and that was wonderful until it cooled down and got a little hard. Would prefer a warm roll instead of toasted.Prices are great and the service was A+. Cannot wait to go back. We live in Gaylord, but will definitely go back when we visit Petosky.“

3.3 Good74 Reviews
Little Caesars Pizza Pizza • $
1099 U.S. 31 N, Petoskey

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza

“Everytime I go there the pizza is great. But I wanted to make sure I did a shout out to an employee each time I’ve called In for an order or got an order through the drive through, he had had EXCELLENT customer service. I was told his name was Deegan. (Sorry if I spelt that wrong)“

2.9 Average48 Reviews
Loading...
map Map