Mighty Fine Pizza
$ • Pizza, VegetarianAbout Mighty Fine Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Riley Cinn Sugar Pizza Bites with Dipping Frosting
Chicken Parmesan Grinder
Cheese and One Topping
Pizza Burgers and More
Pep & Cheese Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Keto Pizza Bowl
Chicken Caesar
Chicken Wings
Mexican Pizza
Mighty Fine Pizza Reviews
228 ratings
Share your opinion about Mighty Fine Pizza
I genuinely don’t understand how this place doesn’t have even better reviews. The pizza was SO good, easily the best and very had in petoskey. Everything tasted fresh, the crust was perfect, and we absolutely loved it. On top of that, the staff and owner were incredibly nice and friendly. This place deserves way more love, and we’ll absolutely be back!
I critique Pizza all over and have been many places. Mighty fine has a really good pizza as the name suggests. I love the way the crust tastes. Cheese is good and it's always cooked perfect.
Best food I’ve ever had. Customer service is immaculate, they messed up my order and were incredibly kind and understanding, gave me the incorrect portion for free and everything. Incredibly kind people and I eat here whenever in petoskey.
Go here.
Go here.
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 3 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 3 - 8PM |
Mighty Fine Pizza is a family-owned business that stands out for its deep-dish pizza, which is highly praised for its generous cheese, the right amount of sauce, and a fantastic crust. The restaurant is committed to making everything from scratch, including the dough, which sets it apart from chain restaurants. Customers can enjoy their meal at home or downtown in the summer, with great phone staff and delivery service.
Visitors describe the food at Mighty Fine Pizza as "amazing," with generous toppings and a delicious sauce. The family-owned and operated establishment is a local favorite, recommended by staff at nearby hotels. In addition to the popular pizza, the restaurant offers fresh and thoughtfully-crafted salads, including a large "small" Chef salad that can feed two people. While some find the crust on the regular pizza too thick, the personal pan size is perfect.
Customers praise the freshly made bread, amazing sauce, and well-layered toppings that provide good value for money. The restaurant's small storefront may not offer a dine-in atmosphere, but it more than makes up for it with its terrific deep-dish pizza, featuring a soft crust, perfect seasoning, and generous cheese. With reasonable prices and a friendly staff, Mighty Fine Pizza is a beloved destination for both locals and travelers, offering a variety of delicious homemade options.