Mighty Fine Pizza
222 E Mitchell St, Petoskey
(231) 347-3255
Customers' Favorites
Riley Cinn Sugar Pizza Bites with Dipping Frosting
Chicken Parmesan Grinder
Cheese and One Topping
Pizza Burgers and More
Pep & Cheese Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Keto Pizza Bowl
Chicken Caesar
Chicken Wings
Mexican Pizza
Menu
Photos
+50 photos
+49 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
What a happy find!! We arrived to our hotel to tired to go out to eat. Came across Mighty Fine Pizza when searching delivery options. The pizza was outstanding. Wings were meaty and their rub n sauce delicious. Don't skip ordering their Might Fine Salad- definitely add one to your order. Everything was delivered hot and fresh. Staff very pleasant. I only wish they were in my hometown.
Service was great! We got delivery to the marina and they were really nice about it. I believe we ordered the Greek pizza. Super good! Crust is perfect—if you like thin crust. It’s tasty and compliments the rest of the pizza versus taking over like other pizza crusts do.
The toppings were plentiful and just the right amount.
You can tell they care about their pizza!
The toppings were plentiful and just the right amount.
You can tell they care about their pizza!
We were in the area for our Anniversary and based on previous reviews we had to try the pizza. It is Take-Out only, but they had outdoor seating available along the sidewalk which we enjoyed on the cool, breezy evening. We even enjoyed the crust that was a good balance between soft and crispy. We definitely recommend this place when you're looking for some mighty fine pizza.
You May Also Like
Malted Vinyl - 316 E Mitchell St
![]()
Lounges
The Reel Deal • Fish and Chips - 425 Michigan St
![]()
Fish & Chips