Pizza Restaurants near Otsego

“Mannies is a restaurant known for its delicious spaghetti sauce and fabulous meatballs, reminiscent of a homemade recipe from Brooklyn, NY. The pizza has been highly praised for its great taste and service, making it a preferred choice over corporate stores. The restaurant has a cozy, small-town feel and offers ample parking. They offer a variety of pizzas, including a spicy sausage option. The breadsticks with mozzarella are also a popular choice. Overall, Mannies is a great spot for those seeking delicious Italian food.“

“Pizza Perfect is a local favorite for its delicious and customizable pizzas. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the menu offers a variety of options, including the popular chicken bacon ranch, mango chicken habanero, and breakfast pizza. Customers can call ahead to order a whole pie or have it delivered. While the vegetarian options are limited, the pizza is praised for its fresh ingredients, tasty sauce, and overall quality, making it a worthwhile destination even for those outside the immediate area.“

“Papa Murphy's Take 'N' Bake Pizza is a popular choice for those who enjoy customizable pizzas with various dietary options. The restaurant offers thin crust pizzas, desserts, gluten-free, and keto-friendly choices. The pizza chain is well-regarded for its quick and delicious meals, making it a convenient option for a satisfying dinner. While some locations may be limited, customers have expressed disappointment when a store closes and hope for its return. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible with its small and easily navigable space.“

“Arena's Pizza Martin offers a diverse menu with tasty pizza, including the popular BBQ chicken pizza, as well as a variety of vegetarian options and gluten-free crust. The restaurant provides great customer service and has a spacious parking lot, making it a convenient choice. Customers praise the delicious food, from the meat lovers pizza to the cheesy bread, and consider it a reliable and satisfying dining experience.“

“BC Pizza Plainwell-Otsego is a casual dining establishment known for its friendly service and lively atmosphere, especially on karaoke nights. The pizza is described as "okay" by one reviewer, while another praised the "amazing" Chicken Parmazeti and cheesy breadsticks. The restaurant is praised for its welcoming environment, with the staff going out of their way to make customers feel at home. Overall, BC Pizza Plainwell-Otsego offers a pleasant dining experience for those passing through the Plainwell-Otsego area.“

“Pizza Hut offers great food with quick seating and very friendly, kind, and helpful staff. The staff makes customers, including children, feel welcomed and included. The pizza is consistently delicious, and the overall experience is pleasant, even for carry-out orders.“

“Genos Golden Pizza, also known as The Big G, is a restaurant known for its delicious pizza. The pizza has been described as great, with the first bite earning high praise from customers. The nachos and buffalo chicken grinder are also popular choices. While the atmosphere is described as just okay, with a bit of a cold temperature and limited parking, the service is noted as good. The restaurant has a bar area, a middle dining area, and a dining room that resembles a small-town pizzeria. The restaurant also offers flavored Long Island Iced Tea, including a strawberry version. A young male delivery person with long hair has been praised for his friendliness and politeness.“

“Joe's Pizza & Sports Bar offers a lively atmosphere with a wide selection of drinks and classic American fare. The bartender is praised for their attentive service and creative cocktails, including a delightful pink fruity drink and expertly-mixed whiskey sours. The restaurant's decor features an array of football helmets and old sports recaps, creating an engaging sports-themed ambiance. While the food quality is described as 'alright,' the server is noted for their promptness and kindness. However, some guests have expressed concerns about the restaurant's ventilation and the open entrance during inclement weather.“

“Dave's BAR offers a great atmosphere on weekends with karaoke and sports games, along with a kid-friendly environment featuring arcade games, pizza, and small bites. Enjoy friendly staff, amazing wings, onion petals, and great drinks at awesome prices.“

“Little Caesars Pizza serves classic dishes like single layer lasagna. While some find the food typical, others are disappointed with the "cardboard pizza." The restaurant can be busy, but ordering ahead helps. Parking is usually available, making it a convenient option despite its drawbacks.“