Maybe they sell good stuff. I wouldn’t know. I ordered some stuff for Christmas weeks prior to the holiday and checked to make sure the estimated delivery would be on time. Well, they completely failed me. The estimated delivery was Dec16th but my real delivery is going to be December 22. Too late. I’ll be gone and the delivery will sit in front of my house worthless for the holiday. I’m actually quite angry and left without a Christmas present for someone.
Lynn Bawden Zollner
I almost wish I had never discovered American Spoon on our recent vacation to Saugatuck, MI, because now I’m obsessed!! Everything I have tried is 100% amazing! Thankfully they ship their delicious products so I can get my fix here in PA. Literally everything is next level. The pasta sauce? Better than Nonna’s homemade.
Teresa Ball Reidel
I bought the cherry margarita mix, the regular margarita mix & the paloma mix. So far I’ve only tried the cherry margarita but it was delicious & everyone loved it. I also bought the caramel sauce & hot fudge sauce & they are incredible! Everything came packaged beautifully. Super fast shipping. I will definitely be ordering more!
HIGHLY recommend!!!
Cindy Mauch
The amount of styrofoam used to package up two small jars of jam was unforgivable.
Alex “Al”
Unique flavors. My Favorite gelato store in town. I love the chamomile flavor goes great with the Michigan blueberry. If you like yours in a waffle cone, bring your own like I did ?. The don’t offer cones unfortunately.
Adam Horowitz
Been a few years since I was last here - wonderfully surprised. The flavors are great. Wildflower honey tastes like dipping right into the honey jar. Toasted marshmallow tastes like it was roasted on a campfire. Yum.
Annelisa Price
The service was friendly, and the Gelato was delicious! The vibe inside the store was very relaxing, friendly, and aesthetic! Even the music was at the perfect volume to hold conversations (not too loud or too quiet). Definitely recommend!
Laura Froelich
They no longer serve lunch — only gelato.
Clifton Porter
A+ for Gelato. Some of the best Gelato or Ice Cream I’ve ever had.The rest of American Spoon’s stuff is decent too, but go for the Gelato.
The wildflower honey is the best flavor. The raspberry and peach are also great. A good lighter alternative to ice cream.
Kate Nicefield
Very good gelato! Perfect for enjoying on a summer's day while exploring downtown Petoskey. I tried the pumpkin pie special and it really hit the spot. Perfectly spiced and delicious. My partner tried the almond honey flavor and it was also quite good. Just the right amount of nuttiness with the smooth sweetness of honey. You really can't go wrong with any of their offerings.
Anthony C.
Pricing is quite high for what you actually get. Flavors were solid but what you get is small compared to the high price that is currently being charged at this store.
Benjamin Moe
My wife and I stopped for a treat while wandering the area and my wife said that her vanilla was really good. I got the pineapple - which tasted really good but was more of a fruit smoothie with pineapple fibers throughout. I’ve never had a fruit flavored gelato so that might be normal. Not bad but not what I was expecting. We’ll likely stop in next time we’re in town and I’ll give the tried and true flavors a shot.
Kelly Ann Riley
This place was so delicious. I loved the wildflower honey and the coffee flavors. I wish there was a location near me. Staff was friendly and the town is lovely.
Maybe they sell good stuff. I wouldn’t know. I ordered some stuff for Christmas weeks prior to the holiday and checked to make sure the estimated delivery would be on time. Well, they completely failed me. The estimated delivery was Dec16th but my real delivery is going to be December 22. Too late. I’ll be gone and the delivery will sit in front of my house worthless for the holiday. I’m actually quite angry and left without a Christmas present for someone.
I almost wish I had never discovered American Spoon on our recent vacation to Saugatuck, MI, because now I’m obsessed!! Everything I have tried is 100% amazing! Thankfully they ship their delicious products so I can get my fix here in PA. Literally everything is next level. The pasta sauce? Better than Nonna’s homemade.
I bought the cherry margarita mix, the regular margarita mix & the paloma mix. So far I’ve only tried the cherry margarita but it was delicious & everyone loved it. I also bought the caramel sauce & hot fudge sauce & they are incredible! Everything came packaged beautifully. Super fast shipping. I will definitely be ordering more! HIGHLY recommend!!!
The amount of styrofoam used to package up two small jars of jam was unforgivable.
Unique flavors. My Favorite gelato store in town. I love the chamomile flavor goes great with the Michigan blueberry. If you like yours in a waffle cone, bring your own like I did ?. The don’t offer cones unfortunately.
Been a few years since I was last here - wonderfully surprised. The flavors are great. Wildflower honey tastes like dipping right into the honey jar. Toasted marshmallow tastes like it was roasted on a campfire. Yum.
The service was friendly, and the Gelato was delicious! The vibe inside the store was very relaxing, friendly, and aesthetic! Even the music was at the perfect volume to hold conversations (not too loud or too quiet). Definitely recommend!
They no longer serve lunch — only gelato.
A+ for Gelato. Some of the best Gelato or Ice Cream I’ve ever had.The rest of American Spoon’s stuff is decent too, but go for the Gelato.
Best Gelato I have had in America, by far!!
Restaurantji Recommends
The wildflower honey is the best flavor. The raspberry and peach are also great. A good lighter alternative to ice cream.
Very good gelato! Perfect for enjoying on a summer's day while exploring downtown Petoskey. I tried the pumpkin pie special and it really hit the spot. Perfectly spiced and delicious. My partner tried the almond honey flavor and it was also quite good. Just the right amount of nuttiness with the smooth sweetness of honey. You really can't go wrong with any of their offerings.
Pricing is quite high for what you actually get. Flavors were solid but what you get is small compared to the high price that is currently being charged at this store.
My wife and I stopped for a treat while wandering the area and my wife said that her vanilla was really good. I got the pineapple - which tasted really good but was more of a fruit smoothie with pineapple fibers throughout. I’ve never had a fruit flavored gelato so that might be normal. Not bad but not what I was expecting. We’ll likely stop in next time we’re in town and I’ll give the tried and true flavors a shot.
This place was so delicious. I loved the wildflower honey and the coffee flavors. I wish there was a location near me. Staff was friendly and the town is lovely.
Loading...