Mighty Fine Pizza
222 E Mitchell St, Petoskey
(231) 347-3255
Customers' Favorites
Riley Cinn Sugar Pizza Bites with Dipping Frosting
Chicken Parmesan Grinder
Cheese and One Topping
Pizza Burgers and More
Pep & Cheese Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Keto Pizza Bowl
Chicken Caesar
Chicken Wings
Mexican Pizza
Menu
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This is what real pizza tastes like! Bread that actually tastes freshly made, plus the sauce is amazing. And they layer the toppings on really well so you definitely get a pretty good bang for your buck getting extra toppings. Highly recommend!
First time here. We were looking for more of a dine in atmosphere- and this was not the case. Just a tiny storefront, with one little table out front.
What is didn’t offer for a dine in experience, it more than made up for in their terrific pizza! The deep dish was wonderful- soft crust, perfect seasonings, just enough sauce without making it soupy, and generous cheese.
Reasonable prices, decent sized menu, friendly staff. Parking MAYBE up in front, but there’s...
What is didn’t offer for a dine in experience, it more than made up for in their terrific pizza! The deep dish was wonderful- soft crust, perfect seasonings, just enough sauce without making it soupy, and generous cheese.
Reasonable prices, decent sized menu, friendly staff. Parking MAYBE up in front, but there’s...
Mighty Fine is the go-to for homemade pizza in Petoskey! The lobby may be small, but the pizzas are filling! If you live in the area, or camping at one of the state parks for the weekend, I highly recommend trying out their menu! Do note that they do take-out, and delivery only, but there are many places where you can sit down and eat around the city!
You May Also Like
Malted Vinyl - 316 E Mitchell St
![]()
Lounges
Full Moon Pizza - 425 Michigan St
![]()
Pizza, Food Trucks, Pet Friendly