18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Plymouth

“This is place is always busy because the pizza's are great. Very authentic pizza. We get pizza's from here at least once a month. They don't like customization much which is the only downside. There is a no dairy free cheese, which is fine, but would be great if they did offer it. The sauce and dough is all you need to enjoy the pizza.“

“Main Street Pizza is hands down one of the best spots in downtown Plymouth. From the moment you walk in, the staff makes you feel genuinely welcome — friendly, attentive, and clearly proud of what they do.

The food is outstanding every single time. The pizza is perfectly cooked with fresh ingredients, great flavor, and that ideal balance of crust, sauce, and cheese. You can tell real care goes into every order. Everything comes out hot, fresh, and exactly the way it should.

What really sets this place apart is the staff. They’re fast, professional, and always positive, even when the place is busy. It’s rare to find a restaurant where both the service and the food are this consistently excellent.

If you’re in Plymouth and looking for great pizza with even better people behind the counter, Main Street Pizza is a must. Highly recommend and will absolutely keep coming back!“

“Excellent place, good food really nice staff.😀😀“

“just had the burger and frys. really good..“

“I highly recommend this location for your orders. This was my first time ordering, and when a delivery issue (partially on me) arose, they listened to my frustration over the phone with so much patience and understanding. What they did next went above and beyond—it was more than expected and demonstrates that customer satisfaction is truly essential for them. I especially appreciated them following up by returning my call. Thank you again!“

“YUM! From pizza and burgers to cold brews, CJ's has it all. And they have great deals throughout the week. I cannot tell you how many pizzas I've ordered from CJ's (not because I can't count the number but because it's a bit much. 😉).“

“This is a hidden gem in cand can't the party stores been there forever? But the pizzeria is right in the center. It is made consistent. It's a great Bang for the buck and the quality is fantastic. I would highly recomman fairly priced. Great food.
By the way I love their meatball sub“

“great Italian subs guys. fresh hot and in and out the door in a minute. if a person loves subs this is the place to go.“

“I had a great experience tonight after what could have been a terrible one. The came and personally delivered my pizza with his apology. I would definitely recommend this place. Great customer service!! Thank you 😊“

“Chicken wings are so good must try“

“Jets has always been a quality pizza place but I stopped going years ago due to prices and the shrinkflation. The Jet Boat is back to full size and my favorite thing on the menu though, so I'm a customer again! This location is fast and the employees are always nice and friendly.“

“This has been on my list of wood fired pizza places to try for quite some time. I had the SALUMERIA pizza
house blend mozzarella, pepperoni, pancetta (Italian bacon), house made sausage.
The flavor was excellent with a slightly crisp crust, just how I like it.“

“Enjoyed a delicious lunch here today. Food was fabulous, Natalie (server) was excellent. I would recommend asking for her next time you dine here.“

“Belt Busters is THE Best pizza in this part of town!! Highly recommend!!🍕😎🍕“

“The girl at the front seemed bored and like she hated her job, couldn’t even get her to acknowledge me as I stood waiting at the portal because they forgot my sauce(or it didn’t fit as I ordered a lot). Aside from that, the food was good, on time, and when I realized I forgot my brownie, I actually got someone to pick up the phone. I was able to go back and pick it up, ultimately I did forget -however, nobody bothered to realize it was missing. But, no big deal. The amount of staff seems to be improving, as does the food quality; I wish the staff working the front was a little more friendly.“

“Stella's has a very friendly and accommodating atmosphere. Everyone is welcome here! The Bartender's, Servers and the Chefs are all top notch! Once you give it a try this won't become your regular hang out!“

“Whenever I'm the Plymouth area I make a point to make sure I stop at this Jets location. I live in Canada in Windsor across from Detroit. Usually I come to the USA approximately once or twice a month. This is the BEST PIZZA I have ever had. John & Nate treat me like royalty and most importantly they make a fantastic pizza. Better than any pizza in Canada that I have ever had. Wish I could give you more stars... Gary.T“