Fireside Inn
$ • Bars, Pizza, AmericanAbout Fireside Inn
Customers' Favorites
Medium Supreme Pizza with Banana Peppers
Elk Chops with Cherry Sauce
Pretzel Sticks
French Dip
Fireside Inn Reviews
193 ratings
Share your opinion about Fireside Inn
I find it very hard to find a good restraunt in the thumb. They are either to expensive,to far of a drive,or Gordon's food service. This place has the best food around. It has something for a lower budget like pizza but also has special and unique food like crab cakes. Sometimes there is a long wait but they stay so busy and it gets a little frustrating but it's worth the wait!
We called in late after we got off the water and the staff was so accommodating! We had 2 amazing pies cooked to perfection! The owner even came out to chat as it was the end of his shift.
Absolutely wonderful staff! Steak was fantastic - better than a steak house! The other people in our party agreed.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4 - 8PM |
| Friday | 4 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 4 - 8PM |
The Fireside Inn is a popular restaurant that offers a mix of dining experiences. While some customers have reported inconsistent food quality and service issues, the majority of reviews praise the establishment's delicious pizza, baked spaghetti, and overall atmosphere. The restaurant's interior has a rustic, "up north" vibe, creating a cozy setting that many enjoy. It can get quite busy, especially on summer Friday and Saturday nights. Customers appreciate the variety of menu options, including pizzas with generous toppings, burgers, and sandwiches. The staff is often praised for being friendly and efficient, even during busy times, with servers providing quick service and a welcoming atmosphere. The place also features a small arcade area and pool table, adding to the fun experience. Despite some minor issues, the Fireside Inn remains a favorite for locals and visitors alike, with many planning to return and continue making memories at this lively spot.