Pumpernickels
202 Butler St, Saugatuck
(269) 455-5299
Customers' Favorites
Blackened Mahi Tacos
Vegetarian Omelette
Crab Cake Benedict
Bloody Mary Bar
Reuben Sandwich
French Toast
Eggs Benedict
Crab Cakes
Menu
Photos
+54 photos
+53 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Quickly seated outdoors and throughout our lunch the service was very good. Menu is a bit small with sandwiches and salads the main features.\n\nMy wife got the avocado toast and she really enjoyed it. She noted the freshness of the toppings.\nI ordered the Reuben which comes with fries. The bread was good as was the meat - the only downside was there was essentially no kraut. But overall a solid sandwich and the fries were excellent.
We are in Saugatuck on vacation and have eaten here three times because it simply is the best place we’ve found to eat in Saugatuck. Food is fresh, creative, and so tasty. The Mediterranean couscous salad and Brussel kale Caesar are beyond delicious. The Maui sandwich was superb. Today my hubby got the burger and said it was the best burger he has ever eaten. The wait staff were professional, friendly, and attentive each time we dined there. This is a must try in Saugatuck....
So we’ve had a place in town four years now and every year we pick a restaurant and write a review. This year we decided to pick pumpernickels to write a review. Reason we picked “pumps” is we heard there was a new owner and we wanted to check it out, we could tell something was going on this winter/spring with all the remodeling going on every time we walked by. Dom our server confirmed that there is a new owner and we met her, and she did a great job remodeling this place....
You May Also Like
Charlie's 'Round the Corner Ice Cream - 132 Mason St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream, Vegan
Phil's Bar & Grille - 215 Butler St
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Bar, New American, Vegetarian
Sand Bar Saloon - 141 Butler St
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar