South Pier Creamery & Market
407 Phoenix St, South Haven
(269) 767-7198
Customers' Favorites
Coconut Almond Fudge
Mackinac Fudge
Ice Cream Cone
Hot Fudge
Menu
Photos
+13 photos
+12 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Had 2 sorbets & 2 ice cream flavors. Was leaning towards the Butter Pecan as a flavor we rarely get, but the server talked me into the black cherry. Planned on 1 scoop, but ended up with 1 scoop of each. She was right, black cherry was creamy & delicious. It wins #1. Butter Pecan was also good, but some spoonfuls fell slightly flat. Overall enjoyed this needed dessert. Woohoo!
One of the main reasons I started visiting South Haven was to visit Sherman's ice cream. Unfortunately as we all know, they were sold a few years ago and closed last year. I was happy to find South Pier and see that they sell multiple brands and actually have 3 Sherman flavors. The portions are quite generous, especially the waffle cones.
South Pier Creamery & Market: The Dairy Gods Have Spoken
Listen, I came for “just one scoop” and left with three pints, a waffle cone the size of a toddler, and a newfound respect for cows.
The ice cream? Creamy. Dreamy. Possibly life-altering. I asked what the most popular flavor was and the cashier didn’t even hesitate. I respected the confidence, so I ordered it—and now I see in color again.
Staff was friendly...
Listen, I came for “just one scoop” and left with three pints, a waffle cone the size of a toddler, and a newfound respect for cows.
The ice cream? Creamy. Dreamy. Possibly life-altering. I asked what the most popular flavor was and the cashier didn’t even hesitate. I respected the confidence, so I ordered it—and now I see in color again.
Staff was friendly...
You May Also Like
Black River Tavern - 403 Phoenix St
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Bar, Fish & Chips, Pet Friendly
The Flying Saucer - 413 Phoenix St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Bagels, Coffee