South Pier Creamery & Market
407 Phoenix St, South Haven
(269) 767-7198
Customers' Favorites
Coconut Almond Fudge
Mackinac Fudge
Ice Cream Cone
Hot Fudge
Menu
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
One of the main reasons I started visiting South Haven was to visit Sherman's ice cream. Unfortunately as we all know, they were sold a few years ago and closed last year. I was happy to find South Pier and see that they sell multiple brands and actually have 3 Sherman flavors. The portions are quite generous, especially the waffle cones.
South Pier Creamery & Market: The Dairy Gods Have Spoken
Listen, I came for “just one scoop” and left with three pints, a waffle cone the size of a toddler, and a newfound respect for cows.
The ice cream? Creamy. Dreamy. Possibly life-altering. I asked what the most popular flavor was and the cashier didn’t even hesitate. I respected the confidence, so I ordered it—and now I see in color again.
Staff was friendly...
Listen, I came for “just one scoop” and left with three pints, a waffle cone the size of a toddler, and a newfound respect for cows.
The ice cream? Creamy. Dreamy. Possibly life-altering. I asked what the most popular flavor was and the cashier didn’t even hesitate. I respected the confidence, so I ordered it—and now I see in color again.
Staff was friendly...
My boyfriend and I visited for the weekend and stopped in here twice while we were heading to the pier, and we love it. I’m thoroughly impressed by their massive selection of flavors and overall menu, but I’m especially appreciative of the multiple dairy-free options for me. The workers were really accommodating and let me try several samples of the df flavors, all of which were great, but their coconut blueberry was by far the best and the flavor I got a second time. My boyfriend...
You May Also Like
Black River Tavern - 403 Phoenix St
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Bar, Fish & Chips, Pet Friendly
The Flying Saucer - 413 Phoenix St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Bagels, Coffee