Bay Pizzeria
100 Cedar St, Suttons Bay
(231) 866-4494
Customers' Favorites
Greek Salad
Menu
Photos
+2 photos
+1 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Best meatball sub I’ve ever tasted.
Sub ingredients are NYC deli quality. Check this place out for subs and calzones. Lilly, that works the front always has a smile on her face and is super friendly.
Sub ingredients are NYC deli quality. Check this place out for subs and calzones. Lilly, that works the front always has a smile on her face and is super friendly.
The best pizza I’ve had in the Suttons Bay Area with very good crust and lots of fresh toppings. We loved the pizza sauce, too. There are many things I’d like to try here, so I’ll def be a return customer. Conveniently located close to the bike trail. A good choice on a great trail. Unfortunately no seating inside but a few tables outside.
You May Also Like
Boone's Prime Time Pub - 102 N St Joseph St
![]()
Bar, Burgers, Pubs, American, Vegetarian
45th Parallel Cafe - 102 W Broadway
![]()
Breakfast, Cafe, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
Streetside Grille - 111 N St Joseph St
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Seafood, Beer Bar, Vegetarian
Sure, BP has competition. Shady Lane Market makes a worthy pizza. And Roman Wheel’s pies are decent (though the bottoms are greasy). As for Locals Lake Leelanau, their quality is uneven. And 9 Bean Rows can be mighty disappointing....