“I don’t usually write reviews, but Papa John’s at University Ave absolutely deserves one. Every time I order, the pizza arrives hot, fresh, and exactly how I asked for it. The crust is always perfect—crispy outside, soft inside—and the toppings actually taste like real ingredients (looking at you, cardboard pizza chains). Delivery is fast, staff are polite, and they’ve never once messed up an order. Bonus points for the garlic sauce. Seriously. That stuff could solve wars.
Highly recommend if you want consistent quality without the wait. Papa’s got it right.“
“Excellent. I just moved into a new apartment and in the welcome folder was a coupon for a free one topping pizza. Well, that coupon expired 3 months ago. I called them and explained it to them, they honored it. Saved my butt after a day of moving. Thanks!“
“What a difference a day makes, from my Pizza Hut heartbreaking disaster yesterday, to falling in love again with pizza from Papa John's today. The Papa John's stuffed crust, pepperoni and extra garlic sauce is my most recent favorite pizza! My family and I are addicted to their pizzas and fries with lemon pepper too. The delivery service is also very good.“
“The greatest pizza experience of my life. The GM is so friendly!! Obviously the guy left a 1 on the last review was having a bad day. No bugs or cockroaches in my pizza!! Just hot meltiness going down my gullet. Last review should’ve added a photo to prove his nonsense. Thank you Chris and staff!!“