ElMar's NY Pizza
15725 37th Ave N Suite 5, Plymouth
Customers' Favorites
18 Pizza with Pepperoni and Homemade Sausage
Pepperoni Sausage Mushrooms and Onion
White and Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza New York
Boneless Buffalo Wings
Pizza by the Slice
Garbage Pizza
Caesar Salad
Cheese Pizza
Meat Pizza
Menu
Photos
+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
My hubby is from New York, and I brought him to your pizzeria for his birthday for a taste of home pizza . It was so amazing. The garlic knots were on point. He says it is right next to New York Pizza. Awesome work!!! The staff was so friendly and helpful. Keep up your amazing work, and thank you for the great pizza!! This was our first visit, and we will definitely be back! We drove 45 min and so worth it! Pictured is 18" classic pie (cheese pizza), 18" cupped pepperoni...
Kind of weird location, tucked into a corner and when we walked up to it, i started to think that it was just a slot business with a counter for to-go. There is actually a room with tables and chairs beyond the counter. I had seen this place name dropped several times in a local Facebook group for pizza lovers. A bit further away than I normally would go for pizza, but it was worth it. We got the smaller sized whole pie and it was perfect for two hungry people. This is the last...
You May Also Like
The Fox and Pantry - 15725 37th Ave N #7
![]()
Coffee Shops, Kids Activities, Cooking Classes, Coffee, Coffee & Tea
La Cocina de Ana - 15725 37th Ave N Suite 4
![]()
Mexican, Vegan
Jimmy John's - 3570 Vicksburg Ln N
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Parking: Immediate lot fills up quickly at lunch, but neighboring lot provides some overflow parking
Wheelchair accessibility: 1 level, no powered doors