Stillwater Baking Company

What we ordered: heart shape cake, funfetti, white “just married”
What we got: Heart-ish shaped cake, white cake (disappointing when we cut into it as I was excited for funfetti), black “just married” in horrible font and textured piping tip used. Cake was not flattened on top or around the edges. Sloppy border piping.

I wish they told me this may not be in their skill set because I would have went with another bakery. Tasted good. If you can’t do steep stairs make sure you ask if they can bring your ordered items out to you. Nice people.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

By far the best baked goods in stillwater I could not recommend this place enough, I bought the most amazing focaccia and danishes for my parents and it just made everyone’s day. thank you again for the wonderful food!

Amazing cookies. The peanut butter balls are better than any candy i have ever had

I’ve had those peanut butter balls among other tasty treats Cindy used to bring into our work. Great bakers!!

Amazing cookies! Between them and my mom, they taught me all I know about baking. So proud of them and highly recommend there products!

The treats they have are delicious!

Very delicious treats! Give them a try!