Pizza Restaurants near Butler

“We usually have a pretty good experience coming here. On this day, they were the only sit down restaurant open and on top of that short staffed. My husband had called ahead to order my pizza to be ready for us when we got there because I have a tomato allergy and can have the regular pizza sauce. There was some miscommunication/clarification between the employee and my husband and the pizza came out with pizza sauce on it. They quickly got the correct pizza made and baked for me. As for the buffet, they were packed in there but I feel like they kept pizzas out there relatively well. The plates on the other hand were not well kept up with. People were using the to go boxes as their plate.“

“I thought this was a good Casey’s until I got pizza Friday May 29, 2026 6:30 pm. Not only was my pizza slammed together. It was not fit to eat, and I seen the kid in the store, literally cutting the pizza before it was cooked! I’m sorry, but what sense does that make you cut a pizza after it has been cooked in the cheese has been melted, but apparently you don’t have people competent enough to make pizza! It was not fit to eat. I literally threw both pizzas to my dogs and I lost $30. From now on when I need pizza, I will just order it from Pleasanton. At least they know how to cook it and then cut it! This was truly pathetic! Because all this is is common sense! DO NOT ORDER PIZZA HERE!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“this review is for the new Rexburg location in Mother hibbards have stopped in there four times within the last week to try the food and they never have anything in the warmer. no pizzas nothing. I went in there tonight. no food in the warmer. the kids that work there are sitting on the floor up against the wall doing absolutely nothing. Do they only serve Pizza at lunch and zero food for dinner? there's nothing anywhere that says what times they have food what time? they don't have food so tonight I went from hangar 54 right over to Valley wide and got me a personal pizza and now I'm headed to work.“