Pie on the Fly
$ • Bakery
Hours:
614 N Main St, O'Fallon
(636) 294-3300
About Pie on the Fly
Customers' Favorites
Pie on the Fly Reviews
Share your opinion about Pie on the Fly
I tried their pies and cookies for the first time. I disliked pumpkin pie until I tried theirs made with pretzel crust. Not too sweet. Cookies are yummy too, not greasy. I just ordered a few pies for Thanksgiving❤️
Always the best brownie and pies! If you haven’t tried Pie on the Fly yet, you’re missing out!!!
Inquired about an apple pie today. They got back quickly and let them know I would be there today. We got there and they saved an apple crumble for me! The smores brownie was the BEST brownie I have ever had. You can tell everything is baked with love and care! Thank you for treating me and my boys like family. 🫶 We will be back!
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 4PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
People in O'Fallon Also Viewed
Pie on the Fly offers delicious pies, including a coconut creme pie that is a must-try. The couple running the restaurant is known for their kindness and attentiveness to customers' needs, often going the extra mile to create special pies upon request. They provided last-minute pies for Thanksgiving, making them a reliable option for quality desserts. Customers have praised their creativity, with one guest ordering a hunting-themed cake that impressed all the attendees. The owners are friendly and helpful, receiving positive feedback about their service. One customer noted the beautiful cherry pie for Easter, complete with a great sugar glaze and star cutouts. Another customer mentioned a white chocolate banana cream pie for their birthday, claiming it was the best they had ever tasted. A unique request for a Peanut Butter Cheesecake resulted in a dessert that included peanut butter cream and Reese’s peanut butter cups. Additionally, a recent visitor tried the pumpkin pie made with pretzel crust and found it delightful. Customers have also shared their love for the cookies, noting they are not greasy and tasty. The restaurant provided pies for a wedding, with guests calling them the best they've ever had. The quick response about an apple pie and the saved apple crumble made one customer feel valued, while the smores brownie was highlighted as the best brownie ever. It is clear that everything is baked with love and care at Pie on the Fly.