11 Best Pizza Restaurants near Palmyra

“Love this place!! Staff is always super friendly and helpful!“

“Asked for a table because my husband and I are larger people. Waited over 45 min. Finally said we'd take a booth with 2 open tables. One right next to our booth. Ordered our pizza and still haven't gotten it after 25 minutes. Wasn't offered chips and salsa. Which isn't on the menu as an appetizer. I don't recommend this place and probably won't be back. First and last time for me.“

“Beautiful historical building that was restored to better than new. Food and service is great! Very nice restrooms.

Avoid the Tiramisu version of pizza though. The artichokes cause the crispy crust to be soggy. They should probably come up with a different recipe for a signature pizza.“

“Went here last week and had a large pizza with bacon and pineapple. It was hot and fresh and tasted great. A young lady named Jackie was my cashier and she was very polite and friendly. Great service and a great pizza. I will be back and hope to have the same great service and pizza again!!“

“Fast and friendly service. Either in store or delivery. Great food as well.

Vegetarian options: They have a vegetarian pizza on the menu, but you can make your own.

Dietary restrictions: They do have gluten free pizzas and go the extra mile by cutting the pizza with a clean pizza cutter to insure there is no cross contamination.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a handicap parking with in 20 feet from door with room for a slide lift. And the crew are very willing to accommodate any guest.“

“The staff was extremely nice and helpful. I was having a bad day and they all joked with me and made me a great pizza and turned my night around. Great place to eat. Quick service too.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, wheelchair ramp is available.“

“Met the owners on a random stop in. Very friendly, knowledgeable, and passionate about their craft. Fantastic cocktails with very good spirits. One of the best Vodkas I’ve had along with a great bourbon. When I visited (11-18-24) they had an amazing Apple Pie moonshine. I cannot recommend them enough and would definitely say they are worth a detour. We were in on a Monday and were told they do music and have food trucks on weekends. Always a good practice to call and verify this though! We will be returning in the future.“

“Took a cruise up HWY 79 from Elsberry to Hannibal to check out all the fall leaf foliage and stopped in for a late lunch and from Appetizers to the pizza we ordered was all very good and a fair price as well family friendly place definitely recommend“

“delivery was super fast and accurate and the delivery person was very nice. Pizza was very very fresh hot and scrumptious! VERY SATISFIED!! good price good food good delivery! ( we ordered the tastemaker with pepperoni sausage and mushroom light cheese and deep pan crust by the way- HIGHLY RECOMEND IT!!)“

“I’m all for supporting locally owned businesses and I will return but we are there last night and service was extremely slow. Our app took 40 mins to come out and meals 20 mins after that. My chopped steak was excellent. Highly recommend. Our fried chicken Mac and cheese, however, wasn’t very good. Certainly not homemade and almost watery, blah Mac and cheese and fried chicken portion was a bit skimpy. Also, the lighting is too bright, with incandescent tube lighting. Very institutional feel. We’ll go back but will try something else and let y’all know“