Pie Guy Pizza
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
4189 Manchester Ave, St. Louis
(314) 899-0444
About Pie Guy Pizza
Pie Guy Pizza Reviews
Our pizza was raw , like actually raw dough, and still took over 90 minutes for delivery.
We used to really love them, so bummed that it's not what it was. It was so specifically good when it was good, but this is just 'throw it in a box and who cares' pizza now.
Waited two hours for our food (1 pizza and a salad). Finally asked if we were going to get food or not and they said they lost our ticket. Fine. Honest mistake. Took our order again and "lost" it again. We finally got our pizza. We had friends from New York with us and their "New York" style pizza is nothing close to New York. Soooo....if you're looking for New York pizza or service of any kind find another place.
By far the best pizza I’ve had in my life and I’m 40 years old. I’ve tried my fair share of pie across the US and this takes the trophy. Oh ya, you’ll get a trophy too mark my words.
Ratings
Menu
People in St. Louis Also Viewed
Pie Guy Pizza is a popular restaurant in St. Louis, known for its East Coast-style pizza and lively bar atmosphere. The slices are described as huge, and the crust is divine, making it a hit with both locals and visitors. The restaurant offers outstanding service and a great beer selection, creating a welcoming environment for everyone. Although parking can be a challenge, the delicious New York Style pizza and enticing aroma make the visit worthwhile.
With a short wait often due to high demand, Pie Guy Pizza is considered a St. Louis gem for its fresh, hot, and delicious pizza. The restaurant is kid-friendly, featuring games and a pool table, along with clean high chairs. Customers praise the vegan pizza, which some describe as a salad on a slice, although a request for vegan cheese was noted. While the pizza crust is perfect, there were mixed feelings about the cheese. Overall, Pie Guy Pizza remains a beloved spot for its great food and fun atmosphere.