Steakhouses in West Plains, MO

“We are from out of state, a state that knows how to cook. We are currently in the process of building a house in MO, so we are checking out local fairs every time we come down.

Coltons steakhouse in West plains, MO was amazing. They close at 9pm and we arrived at 8pm. We were greeted with a kind face and friendly welcome. We were seated right away and our server, Shaylee, arrived shortly.

We ordered our drinks and the onion blossom to start. The onion blossom was cooked to perfection with a light, crispy dredge. Shaylee came back to check on us and ask if we were ready to order.

My husband ordered the Del Rio Riley medium with a ceaser salad, and loaded baked potato. I order the 12 oz ribeye medium with a house salad and loaded baked potato.

The salads came out first with hot buttered dinner rolls. The salads are very large for being a side dish and filling. The ceaser salad dressing is a bit tangy compared to other ceaser dressings, but non the less tasting. The dinner rolls were hot, crunchy on the out side, and soft in the middle. Perfection with house whipped honey butter.

Shortly our steaks arrived and we were not disappointed. Both of our steaks were cooked as ordered. They both had a nice crust, juicy, with little fat to be wasted. The potatoes were large and loaded with cheese, chives, bacon, and sour cream.

Our server, Shaylee, was absolutely pleasant, smiley, and talkative. We asked her plenty of questions, and if she did not know the answer she asked and came back immediately with the answer. These questions were related to food ingredients in which you can not expect them to know every ingredient. She was very knowledgeable on any other question we asked.

Additionally, Shaylee took the time to talk to us and engage in conversation about where we are from, even asking us questions, and about us moving down here.

There were no extra gratuity charges, or surprises on our check. We were not rushed, or made to feel guilty that it was close to closing time.

I highly recommend Coltons steak house in West Plains, MO and ask for Shaylee. You will not be disappointed.“