Fentoni's Pizza

1018 Lake Park Blvd S, Carolina Beach
(910) 458-7010

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

NY Pizza and Garlic Knots

Pepperoni Pizza Slice

NY Cheese Pizza

Slice of Pizza

Calzone

Photos

+35 photos

+34 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Fentoni's Pizza

Recent Reviews

Ordered pizza and a calzone which were all very delicious. We also ordered the cannolis but were very disappointed with them. The shell was flavorless and tasted odd, very small in size, and way overpriced for what we got.

December 2025

Went on a recommendation and glad I did. I can't explain it exactly but this pizza made me feel nostalgic. Excellent all the way around. Generous with everything. The sauce slightly sweet and perfect. I had a pepperoni and sausage slice. Can't wait to have a fresh pie. They are heavy handed with the cheese so let them know if you dont want a lot of cheese. Seems like their baseline is my vision of extra cheese. Still I'll ne driving happily from downtown to scratch...

December 2025

I’m here on vacation and im glad I picked this place when I was craving a slice. The service is great and this really is super authentic NY pizza. I love the crust! Not too chewy, not too soft, not too thick, not to crispy. Just perfect.

November 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Carolina Beach, NC

Fentoni's Pizza

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Fentoni's Pizza