Capp's Pizzeria & Trattoria

Tried Capp’s for date night after neighbor recommendations. Cozy setting, attentive team, affordable menu, and authentic wood-fired flavors made it memorable.

After long hospital shifts, Capp’s became my comfort stop. Fast pickup, kind service, honest pricing, and consistently fresh New Haven-style pizza.

Ordered catering for my daughter’s birthday. Staff communicated clearly, delivery stayed punctual, and the fresh pasta and pizza impressed guests without overspending.

Grabbed a 16" build-your-own for a small game night and it fed everyone. They confirmed topping limits before I paid, so no surprises. $24.50 is fair for a big, well-made pie.

Ordered the butternut squash salad because I wanted something lighter. They were clear about no substitutions and still helped me pick another dressing. For $13 it was fresh, filling, and packed well.

Tried the Seoul Train pizza and it was a fun mix of kimchi and pork belly. Staff answered my spice question on the phone. $20 felt worth it for something different, and pickup was smooth.

My absolute favorite restaurant in Chatham! The food is fresh and locally sourced, the serving sizes are enough for two meals, staff is always friendly, and the desserts are… can’t have just one!

Always delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Strip mall pizza shop that pretends to be a nicer Italian restaurant. I've been here maybe a dozen times and it's always the same. Expensive, subpar food and poor service. The staff is nice, but ALWAYS slow. Infrequent visits to the table considering the small venue. The waitress always seems MIA. The upcharge on basic side items is ridiculous, as is the 18% takeout fee for putting food in a bag. The last I was there, I got chicken parm and I asked if I could get bread. She said I would get it with my entree. Eh... ok. Then when I finally got my bread with my entree, not when I asked for it, they didn't give me any butter. It took another 5 minutes of keeping my 3 yo occupied until I could ask for that and then almost another 10 to get it because the host said she had to put it in like an order or something. Finally, I said why can't you just get it? It's just butter. When she came back, I got frozen butter for my cold bread. I also had a pasta entree to go and they didn't even bother giving me the bread, which my wife asked for when we got home. So this is it for me. We won't be going back. They are cheap, cut corners, overpriced and slow.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

We were really excited about this place and everything looked good. But what ruined the entire meal had nothing to do with the food. The menu is slightly confusing regarding wings. It say small and large but doesn't tell you price for 12. It's not out of this world to pay $22 for 12 wings. But what really really bothered me was that I asked for a side of blue cheese. They brought me a small container you get everywhere but they barely filled to a third. Never mentioned an additional cost. When I got the bill......$2.50!! for the smallest amount of blue cheese after I already paid $22 for 12 wings. Had the lady told me that it was $2.50 for blue cheese side, I would have said no thank you. $0.50 maybe even a dollar but $2.50 is a rip off! I hope management reads this because It would be a shame you to lose customers just to make a little extra money on blue cheese. At the minimum, make sure your waiters let people know that it's 2.50 for the side of blue cheese

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Outstanding pizza recipes! We’re fortunate to have this place locally!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spinach Gnudi

Burnt pizza, chaotic atmosphere due to large party, minimal service.

We were charged an 18% fee on a takeout order without being told when we ordered or when we picked up and paid. The food was fine but the cheese tasted plasticky so definitely not worth the inconvenience of the fee.

Food: 3

Service: 1

Best pizza anywhere - amazing scratch dough oven charred to perfection with vegetables sourced from local farms...fresh...delicious! You won't be disappointed!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caprese Salad

This place is a gem! Many of the ingredients are fresh and sourced from local farms. Pizza is best I have had outside of Italy! Delicious! Family owned. We will be back at least weekly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5