I Love New York Pizza

106 W Franklin St #2516, Chapel Hill
(919) 968-4224

Recent Reviews

Omer Alavna

The experience was unsatisfactory, primarily due to the staff's rudeness and the high price for what was quite an ordinary slice of pizza, costing $5.56. The pizza itself did not stand out in flavor or quality, making it difficult to justify the expense. The overall experience was marred by poor service and lackluster food, making it impossible to recommend.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Some Guy

Very tasty plain slice . Very sexy guy at the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

shanna darby

Absolutely amazing! The atmosphere was cozy, not much room. Food was so good I could have gone back for a second slice, but there was no way I could another! Slices are very generous, and you can definitely make a pizza taco out of it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice

Tristyn Morgan

BEST PIZZA ON FRANKLIN

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ted Melkoumov

Great job and good pizza. Friendly place and the pizza is delicious. Don't mind the other reviews. While this isn't the cheapest pizza its a good one and me and my wife had a great time after our newborn was born :)Dietary restrictions: Has Gluten Free!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Meat Pizza

David Denmark

I work in the area and have eaten from here a few times against my better judgement. The guy behind the counter is not customer friendly at all. Seems to always have an attitude. One time I made a request for two fresh slices from a pie he had in the oven and he got very aggressive with me. The biggest reason for 1 star is that they recycle unsold pizza from the days prior and will sell this to paying customers. I came in here on Friday Oct 27th, 2023 right around the time that they opened. I noticed there was a lot of pizza already sitting out that clearly wasn’t fresh and quickly was able to conclude that it was old pizza from the day (or days) prior. If I wasn’t in a hurry I would’ve certainly addressed this and gotten a refund. $15+ for 2 slices and a soft drink and I ended up just throwing the pizza out and drinking only the soda. Unless you want to spend a bunch of money on pizza that tastes like cardboard, I’d advise you stay away from this place and try one of the other local pizza spots. Italian Pizzeria III is a spot right down the street from here with excellent pizza and great service. There are also a few chain pizza places on Franklin Street close by.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Isabel Nichols

Love this pizza so much! It hits the spot every time!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza

Henry Dickinson

Gluten free pizza was 17.99. That’s actually wild that they think anyone wouldPay for that, even while intoxicated. The most I’d ever pay for a 12in. Gf pizza would be 12.99. 18 bucks cmonDietary restrictions: No

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Charlotte Goldstein

My favorite place in Chapel Hill. The food is always so good and the service is fast and always reliable. If you are looking for the best pizza in chapel hill, come here! I promise it will be worth it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Chicken Pizza, Cheese Pizza, BBQ Chicken

Tony Dillard

Food was precooked and laying around for flies to crawl on. They have trouble understanding what you are asking for due to language barrier. Restaurant was not clean and not sure how this place stays

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Gus Fraley

Favorite pizza spot of all time! Same great quality as long as it’s been open!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Raymond B.

One of the worst slices of pizza I've ever had. I attempted to make a pizza dough a while back, and it was terrible. That being said, it was actually better than the garbage I was served here, for $5+ for a slice.

Anne-Marie G.

Did we catch them on a good day? What a lovely find. We obviously know this isn't a fine dining spot but for a pizza joint we were pleasantly surprised. Good late night snack, dinner date or homework spot. Catch the game & enjoy some crispy pizza! Maybe slightly pricey but everything is these days. Service is counter service. But totally appropriate.

Vanessa H.

Honestly, not a bad slice. The crust is really nice, but the sauce is lacking a lot of flavor. I'm not really a cheese person, so the amount of cheese on this pizza was fine, but I can see that if you were a cheese lover, this pizza would wholly disappoint you. Good for a late night snack!

John Riselvato

The pizza at Sam's Club is better than this and that's sad. Two slices and drink will run you $13 dollars...

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Load More