I haven’t been here since they had the location across from Sun Valley high. I was feeling nostalgic & decided to stop by and get an old favorite. I ordered the Buffalo chicken pizza. If I’m being honest the pizza was good but if my memory serves me correctly they changed the ranch :( I feel like that was the missing piece. Nonetheless , I’ll be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jeanette Purcell
Craving pizza while in Charlotte NC and this really hit the spot! Originally from NY now living in NJ and I have to say their NY pizza was flavorful and better than some NJ pizza joints. Nice thin crust, balanced sauce - doing it right. Chicken parm hero was also good, hero roll could have been toasted a little more, too doughy for me but that’s just a personal preference. If in Charlotte and in the mood for pizza, stop in, you won’t regret it.
Sheila D.
The best gluten free crust! You'd never know it's gf. I've only done pick up, and my order is always ready, when I arrive. I recommend!
Coolie
Great local pizza spot will high quality ingredients and preparation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pee Dee
First time having lunch here with my daughter. Restaurant is very accessible for wheelchair users and everything was top notch from the service to the food!Wheelchair accessibility: Ample seating and space.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Shelley Snyder
I ordered on DoorDash, and when my food got here, and I opened the box I was a palled. My food was completely burned. I can’t believe that they would have someone deliver something like this that couldn’t be eaten for DoorDash to tell me that they were only gonna give me a five dollar credit and I just spent $24.28 on the entire order.
Food: 1
Natan Shemesh (Catchnatan)
Pizza is simple with great options. Never had a bad meal. Pizza, sandwiches, salads and sides are always on point. Very consistent with the quality. There is a lot of young staff working, but they are very attentive. Place can get busy, but the kitchen is quick to get orders filled. I also like that they sell pizza by the slice!Parking: Between Brooklyn and the Lodge, the parking lot can get full, but plenty within a short walking distance.Kid-friendliness: Big open space, and staff is more than accommodating with my little hooligans and their shenanigans.
I was in NC visiting family on vacation from NY and was craving some pizza. My parents brought me to Brooklyn Pizza and the food was spot on. The atmosphere was amazing and the staff was great. I loved the pizza because it reminded me of a real ny style slice. I would definitely recommend it!!
Pizza was fabulous. The service was spot on. Everybody there is friendly and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carole Meisel
Ordered their delectable garlic knots with a slice. Enjoyed both!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
ananya mehta
i love the pizza here it's amazing and the overall vibe of this place is so nice and chill. pizza was one of my biggest fear foods in ed recovery and when i came back from residential this was the first place i challenged the fear food and the environment to challenge it was perfect (especially since i struggle with eating in restaurants) and the pizza was really good and it made me love pizza all over again. 100000/10 recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Pamperin
Been coming in for lunch here for years. Can get 2 specialty new York slices and a drink for about $10. Pizza is solid, but not spectacular, but they will get you in and your food in front of you quickly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Brooklyn Bridge, Meatza Pizza
kevin C.
The old lady (don't know her name) that is behind the counter (Colony road location) taking orders is the problem at this restaurant...it is not the food. So, I had a problem with this same lady 1 year ago. I stopped going to this pizza parlor specifically because of her for 1 full year. She was incredibly rude and unprofessional to me the first time. You can read that review on Google reviews. I decided to give this place another try after 1 full year had passed: today 11/26/2023. I ordered my pizza and drove to pick it up. I walk in and immediately she approaches me telling me I am not welcome in this place. I tried to ignore her but she persisted. I explained to her again that she was very rude to me. I did not hear her a year ago, and she says I ignored her as she was trying to give me a pizza; I was all the way by the front door on my phone. Can you imagine someone being so agressive 1 year later?? ! I gave my email to a young lady to pass on to the owner so I can talk with him directly. The young lady was a witness to the old lady's aggression today 11/26/2023. I told the old lady that because of how she acted she deserved that bad review on Google. Dear owner of Brooklyn Pizza, she needs to be fired. Owning a business is difficult enough...you don't need this lady sabotaging your efforts. I did not seek confrontation with her. She sought out confrontation with me, and your lady employee saw and heard the old thing. I walked out with my pizza determined to leave more negative reviews.
I haven’t been here since they had the location across from Sun Valley high. I was feeling nostalgic & decided to stop by and get an old favorite. I ordered the Buffalo chicken pizza. If I’m being honest the pizza was good but if my memory serves me correctly they changed the ranch :( I feel like that was the missing piece. Nonetheless , I’ll be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Craving pizza while in Charlotte NC and this really hit the spot! Originally from NY now living in NJ and I have to say their NY pizza was flavorful and better than some NJ pizza joints. Nice thin crust, balanced sauce - doing it right. Chicken parm hero was also good, hero roll could have been toasted a little more, too doughy for me but that’s just a personal preference. If in Charlotte and in the mood for pizza, stop in, you won’t regret it.
The best gluten free crust! You'd never know it's gf. I've only done pick up, and my order is always ready, when I arrive. I recommend!
Great local pizza spot will high quality ingredients and preparation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time having lunch here with my daughter. Restaurant is very accessible for wheelchair users and everything was top notch from the service to the food!Wheelchair accessibility: Ample seating and space.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
I ordered on DoorDash, and when my food got here, and I opened the box I was a palled. My food was completely burned. I can’t believe that they would have someone deliver something like this that couldn’t be eaten for DoorDash to tell me that they were only gonna give me a five dollar credit and I just spent $24.28 on the entire order.
Food: 1
Pizza is simple with great options. Never had a bad meal. Pizza, sandwiches, salads and sides are always on point. Very consistent with the quality. There is a lot of young staff working, but they are very attentive. Place can get busy, but the kitchen is quick to get orders filled. I also like that they sell pizza by the slice!Parking: Between Brooklyn and the Lodge, the parking lot can get full, but plenty within a short walking distance.Kid-friendliness: Big open space, and staff is more than accommodating with my little hooligans and their shenanigans.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Zucchini Fries, Grandpa's Pizza
I was in NC visiting family on vacation from NY and was craving some pizza. My parents brought me to Brooklyn Pizza and the food was spot on. The atmosphere was amazing and the staff was great. I loved the pizza because it reminded me of a real ny style slice. I would definitely recommend it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza
Great place with good people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
NY style pizza, good and cheap.
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was fabulous. The service was spot on. Everybody there is friendly and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered their delectable garlic knots with a slice. Enjoyed both!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
i love the pizza here it's amazing and the overall vibe of this place is so nice and chill. pizza was one of my biggest fear foods in ed recovery and when i came back from residential this was the first place i challenged the fear food and the environment to challenge it was perfect (especially since i struggle with eating in restaurants) and the pizza was really good and it made me love pizza all over again. 100000/10 recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been coming in for lunch here for years. Can get 2 specialty new York slices and a drink for about $10. Pizza is solid, but not spectacular, but they will get you in and your food in front of you quickly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Brooklyn Bridge, Meatza Pizza
The old lady (don't know her name) that is behind the counter (Colony road location) taking orders is the problem at this restaurant...it is not the food. So, I had a problem with this same lady 1 year ago. I stopped going to this pizza parlor specifically because of her for 1 full year. She was incredibly rude and unprofessional to me the first time. You can read that review on Google reviews. I decided to give this place another try after 1 full year had passed: today 11/26/2023. I ordered my pizza and drove to pick it up. I walk in and immediately she approaches me telling me I am not welcome in this place. I tried to ignore her but she persisted. I explained to her again that she was very rude to me. I did not hear her a year ago, and she says I ignored her as she was trying to give me a pizza; I was all the way by the front door on my phone. Can you imagine someone being so agressive 1 year later?? ! I gave my email to a young lady to pass on to the owner so I can talk with him directly. The young lady was a witness to the old lady's aggression today 11/26/2023. I told the old lady that because of how she acted she deserved that bad review on Google. Dear owner of Brooklyn Pizza, she needs to be fired. Owning a business is difficult enough...you don't need this lady sabotaging your efforts. I did not seek confrontation with her. She sought out confrontation with me, and your lady employee saw and heard the old thing. I walked out with my pizza determined to leave more negative reviews.