Proof AKA Paradiso
35 Camden Causeway, Elizabeth City
(252) 333-1575
Customers' Favorites
Pig & Pepper - Twisted Willow Meatballs
Twisted Willow Meat Lovers Pizza
The Mulberry Bush - Flatbread
Tweedledee - Fried Mozzarella
The Looking Glass - Calamari
Paradiso Roma Fried Ravioli
Make Your Own Pasta
Build Your Own Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parmesan
Menu
Photos
+50 photos
+49 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
To begin: I am Sicilian and I'm from New Jersey. In reading prior reviews, I will agree that the pasta was not cooked properly even though it was hand-made. I don't know if the pasta itself was the problem, but it was sticking together and was difficult to eat. That said, The tomato sauce was excellent. The eggplant parmesan was incredibly delicious. My husband had the lasagna, my brother had the chicken marsala and my sister-in-law had the meatballs....all delicious....
This place is a gem. I love that they source locally and make as much as they can in-house. Everything that we ordered was absolutely delicious. I recommend the gnocchi and the tiramisu—although it’s a seasonal menu so it changes. Regardless of the season or menu, this place is a must try and a staple for a good meal.
Just ate here for lunch. Service was good and uneventful. The eggplant parmigiana was delicious. The pumpkin ravioli was mediocre. The ravioli pasta was not totally cooked to true el dente form, and the filling was bland. I think it would do better with more pumpkin with a bit of clove. I would probably also add a sage/butter sauce to the pumpkin ravioli to give it a bit more depth in flavor profile.
You May Also Like
Hoppin' Johnz - 606 E Colonial Ave
![]()
Southern, Bar, Seafood, Vegetarian
Coasters Downtown Draught House - 216 N Poindexter St
![]()
Bar, Pubs, Lounges, Cocktail Bar
Toyama Japanese Restaurant - 218 N Poindexter St
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Vegetarian