Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant

our favorite Italian restaurant in Cumberland co.

My wife and I ordered a large half and half. The bill came and charged me for two large. I tried to explain to the waitress the bill. She said you get charge a whole large regardless if it’s half. WTH!!! I’ll never return!

Little Italy. The name couldn't be more on point. Little is actually an understatement. They literally have 8 booths and 4 tables. Our party of 5 arrived and were told we would have to wait for a table. We noticed that all 4 families at the tables were either still looking at menus, or had just gotten their food, so that would've been a really long wait. We noticed that there were 4 booths available so we asked if we could be seated at the 2 booths that were next to each other. She went in the back to ask, came back and told us they said we had to cram 3 on one side, in a booth that only seats 4. Again we asked if we could just have 2 sit at one booth and 3 in the other. No way 3 people can squeeze on one side of a booth and eat comfortably. They refused again and told us we couldn't do 2 booths because then we would have 2 servers. Makes no sense when the booths were right next to each other. And even still, we would've been fine with 2 servers, 2 checks and 2 tips. We just left and went somewhere else . I've never been to a restaurant that refused to accommodate their patrons.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

At $75 for 2 mid pizzas and a salad that had more feta pieces in it than lettuce pieces they could do way better

Get the lasagna… I don’t even like lasagna is to die for….

Also try the basil pesto chicken salad with extra ranch! It is so good!

Wheelchair accessibility: We strive to accommodate all of our customers needs. Any special requests please call ahead so we can suit your needs

Recommended dishes: Cannoli, Chicken Sorrentino, Seafood Fradiavolo, Lobster Ravioli, Chicken or Steak Stromboli, Tortellini Supreme, Little Italy Spaghetti, Veal Parmigiana, Spaghetti Little Italy Style, Italian, Fried Mushrooms, White Pizza, Spaghetti Carbonara, Baked Ziti, Chicken Bianco, Manicotti, Bruschetta, Chicken Alfredo, Garlic Knots, Lasagna

We got to this place at 8:20 then a worker said they were closed but Google says they close at 9. then said they had to go ask someone so they made us wait 10 mins then the manager came and told us they had no money to pay bills for rent and the workers so that’s why they could not open until 9 and said they only had pizza overall bad service it was 4 of us .

Service: 1

Wonderful like spot for delicious Italian food! The atmosphere is relaxing, the food is great and the service is A+!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Mushrooms, Bruschetta, Lasagna

Faith is an amazing server! Our meal was served quickly. The food was delicious!we will be returning!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very nice staff , great food , and authentic flavors !! Would highly recommend and return back !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This pretty place was referred to us earlier today and it did not disappoint. The staff was very friendly and our pizza was hot and delicious. Faith was amazing. We’ll be back to try something new next time! Thank you for hitting the spot, Little Italy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a great time at this cozy restaurant. Our server Faith was amazing! She was so friendly and very attentive.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bruschetta

As always, everything was excellent tonight! Our server, Alyssa, was fantastic and our food was perfect. Y'all never let us down!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tortellini Supreme

Millie the waitress was amazing.....Chicken Parmesan is delicious..price very reasonable...need more stars on here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian

The pizza I ate today was a pizza Ive ne er eating before the sauce was amazing tastey the cheese sticks were delicious youve got a ten clear across the board from me

I called in for a pizza with cheese and little extra sauce. It came out with everything on top running off the sides of the box. Apparently the guy who took my order didn’t write down the little part of the extra sauce. I didn’t accept the pizza and wanted it remade and told them I’ll be in my car waiting. I waited 15 min and went back to the store and was greeted by a very nice lady who said she talked to the owners on the phone and they said that’s how it’s supposed to come. Thats when we discovered the miscommunication about the little extra sauce, not the full amount of extra sauce. By this point I was late returning to work and discovered they didn’t start making another pizza yet and so I had to wait another 15 min for a pizza. The pizza came out looked better until I got to my car and checked it again and that’s the picture you see with the post. I went back inside and asked for my money back at this point. This is my first time having a problem here and I’m putting this post up as a warning to future guest on how they order pizza from them. Servers were nice and polite and restaurant was very clean. It was the pizza that was the issue. I had to order from another pizza spot and return to work very late. My order was called in at 1:03 and left at 2:10 with no food in hand

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 3