Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant

The margherita pizza tasted more authentic than any pizza I've ever had in the U.S. The waitress was really nice, and the restaurant itself was pretty cozy. I would 100% recommend eating here.

My grandson and I showed up at Little Italy due to Eric wanting Italian, and I got to pick the restaurant. We have never eaten here before.

My grandson loves spaghetti without any sauce, and he likes his bread. The waitress delivered his small loaf of bread with a dish of olive oil and seasoning. A first for him. He loved it! The spaghetti was fixed with a buttery sauce. He ate everything!

I ordered a serving of lasagna, and it came with tasty tomato sauce. I save some for Eric to try, and when he did, he ate the rest of it too.

We will definitely go back again and recommend Little Italy to everyone.

The margarita pizza was watered down

Family of 4 we all got something different. Lasagna, Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Parm and Meat Lovers Pizza. Soup and salad for sides. Lentil soup was flavorful, salad was well your typical side salad. Every thing was yummy! We will definitely be coming back.

Yosselyn was our waitress. She was very attentive and nice.

I gave atmosphere a 3 star just because it was so hot in the building.

Their sanitation grade is 96.5. It was very clean and food came out in a timely maner

Super friendly waitress. The food was amazing. I have gluten sensitivity and they have gluten-free options for pasta and pizza.

This place used to be excellent! It has been hit and miss. My friend and I ordered a grilled chicken salad last night and it was awful! The chicken was not even grilled and we even showed the manager that it was boiled. There were barely any vegetables and it was very bland. It tasted like hospital food. I ended up just leaving it on the table I ordered tea and it was good but when it came to getting refills, our waitress which was the manager said they had thrown it out for the night. They should have asked if we wanted a refill before they had thrown it out. Our dining experience was horrible! Who can't get a grilled chicken salad right? I will now continue to go to Pizza Palace or Sammios if I want a great salad!

I ordered a meat lovers pizza and two pasta dishes and the food was mediocre it was nothing special

Great food, great service, comfortable atmosphere, reasonable prices.

Decided to buy dinner and it’s been awhile since we’ve had their food which was good in the past. Idk if it’s new mgt or just a really bad night but the pizza was horrible. Something has drastically changed

our favorite Italian restaurant in Cumberland co.

My wife and I ordered a large half and half. The bill came and charged me for two large. I tried to explain to the waitress the bill. She said you get charge a whole large regardless if it’s half. WTH!!! I’ll never return!

Little Italy. The name couldn't be more on point. Little is actually an understatement. They literally have 8 booths and 4 tables. Our party of 5 arrived and were told we would have to wait for a table. We noticed that all 4 families at the tables were either still looking at menus, or had just gotten their food, so that would've been a really long wait. We noticed that there were 4 booths available so we asked if we could be seated at the 2 booths that were next to each other. She went in the back to ask, came back and told us they said we had to cram 3 on one side, in a booth that only seats 4. Again we asked if we could just have 2 sit at one booth and 3 in the other. No way 3 people can squeeze on one side of a booth and eat comfortably. They refused again and told us we couldn't do 2 booths because then we would have 2 servers. Makes no sense when the booths were right next to each other. And even still, we would've been fine with 2 servers, 2 checks and 2 tips. We just left and went somewhere else . I've never been to a restaurant that refused to accommodate their patrons.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

At $75 for 2 mid pizzas and a salad that had more feta pieces in it than lettuce pieces they could do way better

Get the lasagna… I don’t even like lasagna is to die for….

Also try the basil pesto chicken salad with extra ranch! It is so good!

Wheelchair accessibility: We strive to accommodate all of our customers needs. Any special requests please call ahead so we can suit your needs

Recommended dishes: Cannoli, Chicken Sorrentino, Seafood Fradiavolo, Lobster Ravioli, Chicken or Steak Stromboli, Tortellini Supreme, Little Italy Spaghetti, Veal Parmigiana, Spaghetti Little Italy Style, Italian, Fried Mushrooms, White Pizza, Spaghetti Carbonara, Baked Ziti, Chicken Bianco, Manicotti, Bruschetta, Chicken Alfredo, Garlic Knots, Lasagna

We got to this place at 8:20 then a worker said they were closed but Google says they close at 9. then said they had to go ask someone so they made us wait 10 mins then the manager came and told us they had no money to pay bills for rent and the workers so that’s why they could not open until 9 and said they only had pizza overall bad service it was 4 of us .

Service: 1