Sweet Tooth Shop

4011 Sycamore Dairy Rd #102, Fayetteville
(910) 868-1366

Recent Reviews

itsbiigdaddyash

PLEASE BRING THE SALTED CARAMEL CUPCAKES BACK !!!!! i swear it was the best cupcake i’ve ever had in my entire life !!!!! ( the pic was definitely after i devoured half of it lmao ? )

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Dozen Cupcakes

Felicia Shehan

Always friendly and the sweets are delicious !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anna LaCroix

I work for door dash and I had a pick up from here. I went in to pick up the order and was so impressed how cute everything was and clean. You just don't know some of the stuff I have seen. I picked up the order and was like these cupcakes look amazing so I got 2 the Neapolitan cupcakes and the birthday cake cupcake let me tell y'all absolutely amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

K A.

Small cozy place, brownie, red velvet cake and turtle cupcakes. They where moist about $3.79 per cupcake

bgladde1

The vegan selection did not taste good. Whatever was in that brownie with walnuts made me physically ill. It tasted inedible. I’ve had many vegan sweets .. these miss the mark. My first time I was there , the person working could not give me any info on the vegan selection. Her answer was idk with a shrug. I do like the atmosphere just wish it was tasty vegan options.

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Vegan, Strawberry

Alexandra Donovan-Moore

i was craving a cannoli and normally go by a pricy grocery store, but wasn’t feeling that - found a place 5min from my house instead. made a call to do curbside pickup because i had my baby with me, and the girl on the phone was so sweet! she brought it out to me as soon as i called that i was there. :) the treats were super yummy. i also got a turtle cheesecake and chocolate covered oreo. all were good but my fav was the oreo, holy cow!! not too overwhelming with the chocolate at all. cannoli was superb. cheesecake was pretty darn good too. will be going here only for my sweet tooth cravings from now on!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristi Huebner

I called to see if they had Gluten Free cupcakes available. They were sold out so the owner asked when we needed them by. I told him we were headed to a birthday party and we have a celiac daughter. He immediately offered to whip some up and said he would have them ready in an hour, and he did! The cupcakes are so cute and our daughters day is made. We also had a frosted cookie, ice cream and a red velveteen cupcake while visiting. All were delicious! We will definitely be back.Dietary restrictions: Celiac friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 8 Cake, Sugar Cookie

April Smith

My son cannot have dairy so we ordered this birthday cake from Sweet Tooth. It was so good! We will be back next year!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

William Keenan

Come for a coffee at least 2-3 times a week.

Jeanne H.

Sweet Tooth catered my wedding and other important events in my life. I got married in August, and people are still talking about the coconut bavarian cream wedding cake. For the wedding cake, I sent over designs and the cake was identical to what I asked for. For other events, I've ordered vegan and gluten-free cupcakes for guests who need them. Every time, they've arrived packaged separately and carefully to avoid contamination. My vegan friend loves the way their vegan cupcakes come out! They also have keto friendly cheesecakes and cookies that are delicious. I will add that they are popular so plan ahead if you'd like to use them for events. Cupcakes are easier to get closer to the event, but if you have your heart set on a cake design from them, you need to get on their calendar ASAP because they book up fast.

Gabriel Hess

They sell your information with a card swipe.I dropped by two weeks ago, bought a cookie with my credit card, did not enter my email address or any other information, and promptly started receiving emails from them daily. Somehow they must have pulled my email address straight from my credit card. Never at any point did I consent to receive anything from them.Bear this in mind--you're giving them a lot more than just your money when you buy from them.

Sarah Drake

Wonderful cake for my daughter’s 30th. She picked out the design and Sweet z tooth made it happen. Thank you!

Meagan Washburn

Working with Sweet Tooth for my son's birthday cake was a great experience from start to finish. Communication from the cake decorator was amazing, and the cake turned out beautifully and tasted great. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for a local bakery for their special occasions cake needs!

Benie Encarnacion

Ordered cake having no experience with company. It was so delicious. The customer service was great as they held the cake for me and assisted with a few request. Everybody was raving about how rich the flavorful the cake was. Thank you

Sarah D.

Ordered my daughter's 30th birthday cake here. They took the picture she liked of a cake and made it in an eight inch. Cake was made as promised on the date quoted. It had black icing so I was hesitant how it would taste but it was delicious. They'll have my business for future special occasions.

Load More