Jeremiah's Italian Ice

Anything you try here you will definitely love and you will want to go back again and again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Oreo Cookie Dough, Chocolate Ice Cream

Always yummy. Owners are nice, and they find the nicest kids to work there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Large Italian Ice, Medium Jelati, Medium Italian Ice, Chocolate Ice Cream, Large Jelati

Since its opening, my son and I have frequented this establishment regularly. On this occasion, I invited a group of approximately seven friends and their mothers to join us, even transporting an additional child from school. Historically, our experiences have been enhanced by the young waitstaff, who demonstrate exemplary friendliness, patience, and attentiveness. Today, however, we encountered an older individual, whom I believe to be the manager.

During our visit, both my son and his friend ordered a small, and I ordered a mini for myself. However, it became apparent that my son received a noticeably smaller quantity than his friend, prompting him to inquire about the discrepancy. A younger waitress courteously rectified the situation by adding more, aligning with the consistently courteous service we have previously received.

It is pertinent to note that my son and I were the only African American individuals in our group, as the remaining children and parents were Caucasian. While the children were eating, they engaged in lighthearted play within the premises, which my son did not participate in as he was focused on his ice cream. However, one of the other mothers observed the manager surveilling the children, and she suggested it might be prudent for us to leave.

As we were preparing to depart, one of my son’s friends (Caucasian) began hitting a balloon, initiating playful interaction. My son, having just finished his ice cream, jumped up and hit the balloon next. At that point, the manager approached my son directly, reprimanding him without addressing the identical behavior exhibited by the other child or any of the other children (who were still playing inside of the establishment). Instead of addressing a child who, of course, was not in the establishment alone, the manager could have and should have requested to speak with myself or any of the accompanying parents to address any concerns. This approach would have been far more appropriate and respectful.

After we left, one of the other parents reached out, because her son expressed his own discomfort and perception of the situation. This shared observation further underscores our concern that my son was unfairly singled out, potentially due to his race.

This inconsistency in treatment was both noticeable and disconcerting, leading us to believe that my son was subjected to differential treatment based on the color of his skin. The incident left him feeling uncomfortable and unwelcome, and it is with regret that we have decided not to return. Despite the convenience of this location and the enjoyment we previously experienced, today’s encounter has cast an irrevocable shadow over our perception of the establishment.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Super nice and charismatic staff, and super good Italian ice! Staff took their time to explain the menu thoroughly. They have Italian ice, soft serve, and then what they call gelati -- not to be confused as the plural of gelato; this means a mixture of both Italian ice AND soft serve. This seems to be their signature thing. You can build your own gelati by selecting flavors and toppings, or pick from a curated menu of popular combinations. We were blown away with their cleanliness, selection, prices and how awesome everything was, oh and the portions are VERY generous! The owners, Angela and Edo, were there and couldn’t have been more gracious. Did I mention they have pup cups too!!! This is now, by far, my family's favorite ice cream shop!!

My family and I had the most amazing experience at Jeremiah’s. The staff was so friendly, the place was impeccably clean and the ice cream was out of this world. It’s my new favorite place to come and enjoy ice cream and just have a wonderful time with friends and family.

Will definitely be one of my weekly stops when I want ice cream. Can’t wait to get back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream

We love Jeremiah’s and take family and friends for a visit every chance we get!

Recently we had a large group of family visiting, it was getting late but we were craving a sweet treat. We made it to the drive through shortly before closing and the staff welcomed us and took care of our large order without any pressure or rush due to our timing. Was a delicious late night treat!
Definitely recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time coming here and it surpass my expectations.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The service was incredible, the place was spotless! The vanilla soft serve was delicious my husband's chocolate icy was good. My strawberry ivy was weak in flavor and the fat to chocolate ratio in the chocolate soft serve was off somehow. There was chunky greasy specks in the chocolate, and not much chocolate flavor. We lived in Orlando for 5 years and Jerimiahs was our FAVORITE place in all the world to go to for ice cream! We were so excited to find it had spread out to other states and we could enjoy it once again as we traveled through, so we were sorely sadly disappointed. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

I'm so glad I discovered this little gem! The store inside is super cute and clean ?, and the girls at the front counter were extremely friendly. There is also outdoor seating for nice days! I ended up getting the pumpkin pie and I was super glad I treated myself- they nailed it!!!!! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It did not start well almost left because the ice cream machine broke. But the staff diligently worked and got it working and that saved the day.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Love this place..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is some of the best Italian ice I have ever had in my live it’s so light and refreshing no artificial taste at all

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Excellent they even have pup cups for free for your furry friends

Delightful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing value and we loved both Gelatis we got.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5