Benny Tesoro's

Name: Benny Tesoro's
Address: 7531 S Virginia Dare Trail, Nags Head, North Carolina, 27959, US
Telephone: (252) 715-1227
Price range: $
Rating: 4.2

$ • Pizza, Italian

Hours:
7531 S Virginia Dare Trail, Nags Head
(252) 715-1227

Menu Order Online

About Benny Tesoro's

Benny Tesoro's serves some of the largest and best pizza slices around, making it a great choice for those craving a delicious meal. With a taste reminiscent of New Jersey and NYC pizzas, this hidden gem is a top-notch pizza joint worth visiting. The slices are impressively large, often leaving families with leftovers, as one family found they could only eat one slice among four. While they may not offer gluten-free options, their single garlic and mushroom slice is incredible and pairs well with a cold beer from the nearby brewery. The friendly staff enhance the experience, and one customer praised a young man from the restaurant who went above and beyond to deliver their order after a mix-up. Benny Tesoro's is truly a must-try spot for fantastic pizza.

This location stands out for its cooperation with the Lost Colony tap-house next door and the beautiful sound-side deck where guests can sit outside and enjoy their meal. The staff here is usually younger, but they run the place very well, making the visit smooth and enjoyable. Customers often comment on the impressive size of the slices and the fresh mushrooms loaded on the pizza, which adds to the deliciousness. The atmosphere is fun and quirky, with cool paintings inside and a beautiful view that makes the experience perfect. Everyone who visits has a great time, and the friendly staff makes sure guests feel welcome. Overall, Benny Tesoro's continues to impress with its giant pizza slices and welcoming environment.